On Wed, 24 Oct 2012 10:55:48 -0500, Paul Gilmartin wrote:

>This design is WRONG!  

I don't think so.  SMS is enforcing corporate policy.  Either
1. The SMS routines do not accurately reflect the policy, or
2. You are trying to violate the policy

>It's fine for SMS to supply elided options,
>but any options explicitly supplied by the programmer should be
>honored, 

Part of the reason for System _MANAGED_ Storage is to reduce the 
need for programmers and other users to have to deal with details 
like where their data will go.  You are suggesting that if I specify a 
volume, the system should always try to use that volume and no 
other, even if there is no space on the volume.  And if the storage 
administrators remove the volume from the system, your job will fail. 
That kind of behavior is unacceptable for a production shop.

>or result in a JCL error _clearly_ describing the cause
>and citing the applicable SMS rule. 

SMS does not have "rules"  It has "routines".  There are four 
Automatic Class Selection routines and each one makes a single 
decision.  The Storage class ACS routine selects a storage class, 
for example.  It does not pass back a reason for the selection, but 
the ACS routine is free to issue messages to help the user.

-- 
Tom Marchant

----------------------------------------------------------------------
For IBM-MAIN subscribe / signoff / archive access instructions,
send email to [email protected] with the message: INFO IBM-MAIN

Reply via email to