> > > >The main benefits of REODERING is not only for very long domains, > >but for average ones. It also helps administation,transcription and eye- > >comparison on the ACE labels. > > It doesn't really help. Transcription and eye-comparison of > ACE labels is a pain. If they are a bit shorter, it still > just hurts.
The pain will be everywhere in mobile devices. That is why The pain-killing drug are in the world. > > > >Moreover, as IDNA I-D recommends, > >ACE labels should be rendered "as it is", > >when the decoded native-label contains characters which > >the rendering engine cannot display. For example, > >if you have _no_ huge han script font set in your mobile phone (or PC), > >the ACE labels for han/hangul email addresses of your friends should > >be displayed "as it is". But, it may be often too long to be displayed > >in your narrow phone LCD lines of width 16~20, without REORDERING. > > Displaying ACE when nothing else is available is acceptable > as a 'best-effort' solution. But it is very far from a good > solution, and designing the rest of IDN for this doesn't > make sense. > > I have no problem with IDNA (if it stays at a SHOULD level), > but on a mobile phone, I would probably just use a few question > marks to make clear that there is something that cannot be > displayed. > CJK peolple have problems without REORDERING. Other european folks but You martin (han experts), won't install han/hangeul fonts even in his/her PCs, i guess. Most europeans will see leaked ACE labels sometime in the future when IDN host/email addresses are everywhere and interchanged globally like LDH ones. surely, IDNA WITHOUT REORDERING also become pains for non-CJK folks. Thanks, Soobok Lee
