Barry Leiba <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > Since experimentation resulted in significant Internet deployment of these > specifications, the DKIM working group will make every reasonable attempt to > keep changes compatible with what is deployed, making incompatible changes > only when they are necessary for the success of the specifications.
I'm generally comfortable with this charter, but not really with this. "necessary for the success of the specifications" seems like a very high bar to clear. While I appreciate that there's a desire by many members of the WG to avoid making incompatible changes (hence this language), to the extent to which that desire reflects consensus, those changes won't be made anyway. I don't believe it's appropriate to rule discussion of changes which might be important but not "necesssary" out of scope in the charter. -Ekr _______________________________________________ ietf-dkim mailing list http://dkim.org
