frankly i am still quite supportive of *cheapo* cards( i have three rtl
8029AS) because they are about half the price, and get my low-end work
done *arguably* perfectly.!

so i'll try to give a line-by-line

> To throw more confusion onto the whole setup, when I used intel 100M cards
> over a switch, I could easily get upto 4MB/sec data transfer for large
> files. 
i believe these are rather slow rates compared to the theoretical
limits.. ever tried making a /dev/shm partition mounted, and try to
transfer from there, or probably from /dev/zero and try that? probably
you'd get to know as to whether the card is at fault or the hdd speed.

> The same machines with Compex cards using some wdxxx chipset would
> give 300k under linux, but around 2MB under windows (The linux driver was
> surely faulty). 
surely. i am using lin-2.4.18-14 (rh8) and i just got average 1004MB/s
for 30 MB file over a p-120 -> athlon 800. (card= rtl 8029AS)

> A RealTek rtl8139(or 29??) based cheapo card would max out
> at 2MB/sec on win-win, win-lin & lin-lin. All these speeds were measured
> using ftp file transfers for large files and idle systems. The 4mb/sec speed
> of the intel cards seemed to be because of the disk throughput. I wonder if
> the intel cards use significantly less cpu to cause such good speeds. 
quite possible. i have no idea on this one, and frankly cant test, since
i have a BNC (coaxial) setup and cant go beyond 10Mbps.. (home network).
but generally do feel proud to note that i get about 700-800 kBps on
win-lin or lin-win .. and a 1000+mBps on lin-lin... but the worst for a
win-win setup..

> I am right now thinking about getting 4 80gb 5400 rpm drives and then
> setting up my celeron 366 on raid 5, raid 1 and raid 0 to see the
> performence i can get out of normal dlink 100mbps cards. That way i will be
> able to measure the effect of lan throughput, cpu speed and linux + samba +
> win2k ;)
all the best, and please post a few results if possible. helps much
better to know whether my darling *cheapo* cards actually max out as bad
as you say it does. 

keep smiling

affly
robins



_______________________________________________
ilugd mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://frodo.hserus.net/mailman/listinfo/ilugd

Reply via email to