Ok.
1. The flags ARE defined on the target mailbox already as all I am
really doing is deleting a message and appending it back to the same
folder slightly modified (annotated) but with the same keywords.
Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't * on the same message with the
same keywords in the same folder *
2. Not true that the append command will not add new keywords. If I do
an append on a folder that has NO keyword other than the "\system" ones
defined and I add a "$Appended" keyword to the set of keywords to be
assigned on append, it WILL get added to the message and folder (in MIX
on the version of UW I am using).
This does not happen with MBX folders, however.
So -- this is behavior I can't rely on... I'll resolve by adding and
removing $Annotated from the message I am going to delete before I
delete it and before I add the new message. However, that doesn't
explain the issue at hand.
3. Here you go on the logs. FYI , I have not been able to reproduce
this yet on an MBX folder ... only on MIX folders.
Successful one:
---------------
Wed Jun 6 21:05:33 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
00000007 APPEND mail/atest (\Flagged back $Annotated) " 4-May-2007
14:14:45 -04
Wed Jun 6 21:05:33 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
+ Ready for argument
Wed Jun 6 21:05:33 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
Wed Jun 6 21:05:33 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
* OK Check completed
[Wed Jun 6 21:05:33 2007] [11989] IDLib::MailBox::DEBUG - IMAP notify:
0: Check completed
Wed Jun 6 21:05:33 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
* 349 EXISTS
Wed Jun 6 21:05:33 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
* 1 RECENT
Wed Jun 6 21:05:33 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
00000007 OK [APPENDUID 1178301857 366] Check completed
[Wed Jun 6 21:05:33 2007] [11989] IDLib::MailBox::DEBUG - IMAP notify:
0: [APPENDUID 1178301857 366] Check completed
Failed one:
------------
Wed Jun 6 20:59:49 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
00000029 APPEND mail/atest (\Flagged back $Annotated)
" 4-May-2007 14:14:45 -0400" {6829}
Wed Jun 6 20:59:49 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
+ Ready for argument
Wed Jun 6 20:59:49 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
Wed Jun 6 20:59:49 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
* OK Check completed
[Wed Jun 6 20:59:49 2007] [11982] IDLib::MailBox::DEBUG - IMAP notify:
0: Check completed
Wed Jun 6 20:59:49 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
* 348 EXISTS
Wed Jun 6 20:59:49 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
* 1 RECENT
Wed Jun 6 20:59:49 2007 Mail::Cclient: [{email1/imap:143}mail/atest] :
00000029 OK [APPENDUID 1178301857 365] Check completed
~~~~~
So -- it looks like there are possibly 2 keyword issues related to
appending and MIX:
1. Appending keywords that do not exist yet should not happen but does
2. Sometimes appending keywords that do exist does not happen. And when
this happens, NONE of the keyword that are being added with the append
get added.
-Erik Kangas
Mark Crispin wrote:
Hi Erik -
The telemetry that you provided is incomplete, as it does not contain
the tagged OK response from your command.
I am looking for a tagged OK related to the APPEND command, something
like:
00000007 OK [APPENDUID 1181165017 1] APPEND completed
or perhaps something like:
* NO Unknown flag: back
00000007 OK [APPENDUID 1181165017 1] Unknown flag: $Annotated
I suspect that that the affected flag(s) are NOT defined in the
destination mailbox. APPEND does NOT create flags, so if they are not
defined in the destination mailbox then they will be disregarded.
-- Mark --
http://staff.washington.edu/mrc
Science does not emerge from voting, party politics, or public debate.
Si vis pacem, para bellum.
_______________________________________________
Imap-uw mailing list
Imap-uw@u.washington.edu
https://mailman1.u.washington.edu/mailman/listinfo/imap-uw
