On Jan 06, Julian Mayer <jul...@corecode.at> wrote:

> given you encouraging answer i hope to be able to make a beta
> release in the next few days.

IMDbPY 4.4 will be out within the week: 4.3 contains a lot of
problems, and in fact you're forced to use the SVN version, now.
Maybe you can wait until it's out.

> anyway, this sounds a bit like "using IMDbPY or distributing a app
> that uses IMDbPY to fetch movie information is illegal, but they
> won't come after you until you make a profit out of it".

No, it's not: as you have said, you're just distributing/using some code,
moreover a code that is far from being specifically tailored to
violate some property (if I just wanted to grab the whole content of
IMDb web server, I'd never use IMDbPY: too slow and too much overhead).
But again: I'm not a lawyer and the law in USA have taken a (not-so-)funny
road since some time, now.

> > Those information are _their_ property, and you must not profit
> > from them.  For no reason and in no way.
> it's a bit disturbing that the data is their property although most
> of it has been entered by users, akin to the gracenote thing.

There are other sources of information about movies out there, even if
none so complete.

> > This means no reselling (of the data or of a service based on
> > that data) and no republishing under no circumstances [2].
> yeah i think so much is obvious.

You won't believe the number of people for who this is not. :-)

> right. therefore i find it a bit weird that they explicitly forbid
> extracting data from their webpage and on the other hand they put
> those useless text database online.

I think the plain text data files are a legacy of the time the
database was non-profit and community-driven.

> the website lists 15.000 now.  which is ridiculous, there surely is
> demand for apps which can fetch movie info from imdb for personal
> usage. that is a scenario they don't seem to anticipate.

I suppose they don't really care - and I guess/hope they have made
their estimations.
It probably makes more sense to aim to the streaming of movies;
after all the client-side computing is dead, isn't it?  We're all
supposed to be living in the cloud within a few years! (no, I don't
buy it, but everyone seems to like the idea so much...)


Bye,
-- 
Davide Alberani <davide.alber...@gmail.com> [GPG KeyID: 0x465BFD47]
http://www.mimante.net/

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This SF.Net email is sponsored by the Verizon Developer Community
Take advantage of Verizon's best-in-class app development support
A streamlined, 14 day to market process makes app distribution fast and easy
Join now and get one step closer to millions of Verizon customers
http://p.sf.net/sfu/verizon-dev2dev 
_______________________________________________
Imdbpy-help mailing list
Imdbpy-help@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/imdbpy-help

Reply via email to