hello why not directly edit OSM and get minutely diffs? you would have up-to-date copy of the database and no problems with points 2-6 on your list (which afaik are not solved by anybody by a decent level of satisfaction).
eg wheelmap.org uses this approach, our freemap services, ... for the end users of your applications/websites, there will no change ("just" change the API server, the menu stays the same). michal On Sun, Jan 11, 2015 at 12:21:28PM +0000, Paul Churchley wrote: > Open Charge Map (http://openchargemap.org) is a mostly open source database > of electric vehicle charging locations.worldwide. It is mostly data entered > and maintained by the community and licensed viaCC BY-SA 3.0 but it also > contains some imported data covered by other licences. > > I am proposing a data bridge between OCM and OSM to: > > - import the 27,000+ locations currently on OCM into OSM > - provide a mechanism to highlight new OCM entries and to port them into > OSM > - provide a de-duplication function to prevent duplicate nodes being > entered into OSM as a result of this import > - provide a mechanism to highlight new charge stations added directly > into OSM as potential new locations for OCM > - provide a mechanism to identify changes in geolocation of stations in > OCM and transferring the new location to the OSM node > - provide a mechanism to identify stations removed from OCM and to > remove the charging station attribute, or the entire node, from OSM > > The licensing issues are not clear to me. The data on OCM is a mix of CC > BY-SA 3.0 and third-party data imported under their own licenses. However, > I do not propose that we import any data other than open data from OCM. In > fact, I propose that we only import the location, to position the node, and > a reference back to OCM. I am hoping that this will satisfy the OSM > licensing requirements as we are not actually storing anything other than > location and a OCM reference. I am also hoping that as the data being added > to OSM is of a very limited nature that it will also make any import and > bridging considerably easier and simpler. > > My OSM experience is limited but I have been an editor for a couple of > years and attended "State of the Map" when it was in Birmingham so at least > I am familiar with the general procedures and I fully appreciate the > importance of licence compliance and the importance of data integrity and > protection within OSM. > > Your thoughts would be appreciated. > > See https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/OpenChargeMap > _______________________________________________ > Imports mailing list > Imports@openstreetmap.org > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports -- michal palenik www.freemap.sk www.oma.sk _______________________________________________ Imports mailing list Imports@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports