a b wrote:
 > ...many bits of software are moving to /usr :)

 > Deliver to /usr; your life will be simpler, many users will thank you,
 > and you won't have this issue.

Consider that if I deliver my software in /usr (as a 3rd party unbundled applications vendor), I run an extremely high risk of:

a) being overwritten by IPS, respectively your own updates

b) my software overwriting your software.

Work is scheduled to alter packaging system to prevent a user from installing packages with conflicting resources. It is actually desirable that some software delivers into the same place to allow it to replace another component.

It appears that these architectural issue have not been thought throughly.

The OpenSolaris distribution, as you are aware, is experimenting with changes that have not yet made it through ARC. Regardless, I don't see the issue here. Ubuntu, et al. are quite successful despite the lack of adherence to the Sys V filesystem specification from a user perspective.

I won't debate the merits, etc. of this with your nor comment on what should or should not be done architecturally as that isn't my responsibility. I'll just simply say that I see no issue with packaging for /usr as most packages are moving towards, and that I believe most users will expect that.

Cheers,
--
Shawn Walker
_______________________________________________
indiana-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.opensolaris.org/mailman/listinfo/indiana-discuss

Reply via email to