Dear colleagues,
I have a question about the usage of the anusvāra and class nasals in Sanskrit,
which I hope the members of this list can help answer. As we all know, while in
manuscripts and older editions, the spelling of class nasals and anusvāras can
be quite erratic, the practice in scholarly editions is to write combinations
of class nasal and stop with the class nasal (e.g. कान्त kānta rather than कांत
kāṃta, अङ्कित aṅkita rather than अंकित aṅkita, etc.).
However, there is also the practice to deviate from this general rule in the
case of verbal prefixes ending in m and compounds whose first element ends in
m: in these cases, anusvāra is employed instead of the class nasal (e.g. संदेश
saṃdeśa rather than सन्देश sandeśa, अस्तंगमित astaṃgamita rather than
अस्तङ्गमित astaṅgamita, etc.). My impression is that this practice is mostly
followed by Western Sanskritists or Western-educated Indian scholars, whereas
many Indian Sanskritist seem to be unaware of this convention (although I might
be wrong on this).
My questions are:
* What is the justification for this practice (using anusvāra instead of
class nasal in the case of verbal prefixes and conjuncts)?
* Is this practice sanctioned by the Sanskrit grammatical tradition?
* Is my impression about the different conventions followed by Western and
Indian Sanskritists correct?
* What is the best practice for scholarly editions of Sanskrit texts? Is it
imperative to use anusvāra in such cases, or would use of class nasal also be
considered acceptable?
Please forgive my possibly naïve questions! Any insights would be appreciated.
Best regards,
Jonas Buchholz
____
_____
Dr. Jonas Buchholz
Heidelberg Academy of Sciences and Humanities
Project “Hindu Temple Legends in South India”
Karl Jaspers Centre
Voßstr. 2 | Building 4400 | Room 004
69115 Heidelberg, Germany
P: +49 (0)6221 54 4095
E: [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]>
W: https://www.hadw-bw.de/htl
_______________________________________________
INDOLOGY mailing list
[email protected]
https://list.indology.info/mailman/listinfo/indology
