Dear Professor Collins, On the relationship between RE 13 and the two so-called Separate Edicts you might have a look at my book The Aśoka Inscriptions. Analyzing a Corpus, Chs. 4 and 10. As I have tried to show, RE 13 is a later addition to the series, together with 11 and 12. The Kaliṅga version consisted of REs 1-10 and 14. So to say that the Separate Edicts have in Kaliṅga come in the place of RE 13 might not be correct. Note that my book, unlike Olivelle's, is not about Aśoka but about the inscriptions as a corpus. With kind regards, Herman Tieken
Herman Tieken 's-Herenstraat 66 3155 SL Maasland The Netherlands 00 31 (0)10 7617502 00 (0)6 14652798 website: hermantieken.com<http://hermantieken.com/> The Aśoka Inscriptions: Analysing a corpus, New Delhi: Primus Books, 2023. https://primusbooks.com/ancient/the-asoka-inscriptions-analysing-a-corpus-by-herman-tieken/ ________________________________ Van: INDOLOGY <[email protected]> namens Patrick Olivelle via INDOLOGY <[email protected]> Verzonden: zondag 11 mei 2025 18:00 Aan: Collins, Brian <[email protected]> CC: Indology <[email protected]> Onderwerp: Re: [INDOLOGY] [External] Fwd: Celebrating one year of "Ashoka" on audio! Hi Brian: Thanks. No, Rock Edit XIII is not inscribed in the Kaliṅga region. In its stead, we have Separate Edicts I and II. Patrick On May 11, 2025, at 10:54 AM, Collins, Brian <[email protected]> wrote: Having recently borrowed this book from my local library through their Hoopla app, I can confirm that it reads well in audio form. The pronunciations, while not always standard, usually are and are always perfectly intelligible. Based on Patrick’s arguments, I’m going to have to revise my Ashoka lectures for next year, though. Are there or are they not inscriptions about the Kalinga war near Kalinga itself? Best, Brian Prof. Brian Collins (He/Him/His) Drs. Ram and Sushila Gawande Chair in Indian Religion and Philosophy Department of Classics and Religious Studies 234 Ellis Hall Ohio University Athens, Ohio 740-597-2103 (office) Sent from my iPhone On Apr 14, 2025, at 9:59 AM, Patrick Olivelle via INDOLOGY <[email protected]> wrote: Use caution with links and attachments. I am not sure anyone would want to listen to rather than read my Ashoka book. But here is a link with 70% discount if anyone feels like listening!! Best, Patrick Begin forwarded message: From: Stacy Ruddy <[email protected]> Subject: Celebrating one year of "Ashoka" on audio! Date: April 14, 2025 at 7:12:58 AM CDT To: [email protected] Reply-To: [email protected] [IMG_7525]<https://cscsk04.na1.hubspotlinks.com/Ctc/T7+113/cscsk04/VWP-B911hz87W4_GF7g96WjJBW2L--MX5vmJ3MN26s6063qn9gW6N1vHY6lZ3lSW5vJhgN4P8086W4TBs5Q3rckzBW4M_1f55HM8phVC7By034Xjg8W3csCFq90M-mTW1FgJ8w2JGHwcW6-YWW87Mtm7qW5tfWh-307ZhpW5kJBxw57Dh3pW1mZm3b8xXzzTW1b-6Ct5w_lsvW10dd597zYr6BW1WDmFr4F_mD4W1NwJqB6YTmP6W5w8MGc5_D479Mt-Qh82ggZpW6QP5CX54JpQZW7fcSnX7HTF5HW6Z2G935VWShfW3xdP7y3CL4d-W9hvZq08cpkN_W6KQQqQ8K3fjff6q3dcq04> Hi Patrick, Happy audiobook anniversary to you! One year ago, your title "Ashoka" was released, and we're here to help you celebrate 🤗. We've created a 70% discount for you to share. What better way to celebrate this exciting occasion than by offering your fans huge savings on your audiobook? The promotion starts today and will be available until 5/1/25. "Ashoka" By: Patrick Olivelle [https://covers.audiobooks.com/images/covers/full/9798855509946.jpg]<https://cscsk04.na1.hubspotlinks.com/Ctc/T7+113/cscsk04/VWP-B911hz87W4_GF7g96WjJBW2L--MX5vmJ3MN26s5_x5nXHsW5BWr2F6lZ3kzW984z8f2JyFLxW6Wpkkr8R5fgDW144P-97GHCDqW8SPcrr6QzyWJW3__b3N5m9MdlW928PJj62QH02W6nr4hM9gLZzxW5Fw0gn8-gqN4W2fWcZ96L_6g0W4HZSrh5D59nWW7T-2sB7ffm10Vqv32n8mQc9mW1Pjwdc1wF4yMVsPL8g3F-_ZfVz_g2t7BGPqKW7rGNnR52dDzFMBDD9kLHdh_VrZwQN8bpzqzW1qX2TV6QJ4VZW4J-f2z8xl2FXW48tDyY4zh21XW2ZvMkP2KycBBN3pSq1RfHQXgW2dKNcX3T_m7dW5rSqfZ7cMkxVN51vYgwQNw5WW8t428-2VVMQMVpcPVy7Vvhw-W2XywLJ8x02tlW4bPsrv7GtpG4W4YQSVH3VlhffVdh0068ZMKF5W52QrLD99N7YZW3HGMkK7t3Z_ff4tZxFd04> Get 70% Off!<https://cscsk04.na1.hubspotlinks.com/Ctc/T7+113/cscsk04/VWP-B911hz87W4_GF7g96WjJBW2L--MX5vmJ3MN26s5_x5nXHsW5BWr2F6lZ3lgW50YH_j6gt0sRW1t_d9L8WgkWSN6ZGj_v8TGQ-W8sWBDY7cYLpsW4sQF7F59PnSrW90qnGM5PVkgfW8bvgLz1Q408LW6Shv0Q5-WHj-W1nQz8T4-JBjHW7qpldt63bkV6VCQxMF1p3j-TW1m3CJK1rqcWrW4wP7BR1Rpn4WW2h14xm8BT7wXTgDTV20wgD2V9nf0R3r6HYlW3-lyGh8ZX5K7W68SVhL7Dw2QQW6M2XBL2sFGpMW8p9tlh5s45qfN5bKDj17BLGCW21h3w0596_0cW1lLl2m1kbVsWN6dpNZnlW7hGW2-kDNv9fcl_zW4jV8dC1NzNdCW50tt_x5TH-8pN3HVqfDtz1c7W2sG_q24jvc6WVWrPTS1CyzNYW8x-K79442y82W6dNX8v4t73R9W1Yfk_k5D0l06W2Mtr_h49WKStf62Ld6404> Sharing the Promotion is Easy (see example below): * Copy and paste the link - https://www.audiobooks.com/promotions/promotedBook/722939/ashoka-portrait-of-a-philosopher-king?refId=187293 - into your browser to view your custom landing page for "Ashoka". * Tap the SHARE icons on the landing page to pull this custom fall promotion straight into your Facebook and Twitter feeds (or tap the + button to share it on other social platforms, your website, or blog). * If you have any issues using the SHARE buttons, simply copy and paste your URL into a social post, goodreads, your newsletter or wherever you want to share it with fans. * Add a message to your followers and click “Post”. That's all there is to it! These promotions have been receiving an incredible response from our authors and their fans. Please note, you will be paid your full standard royalty on all copies sold through this promotion. Sincerely, Stacy Thelin p.s. If you have questions regarding these emails, please reach out to your audiobook editorial contact. PROMOTION EXAMPLE Our proprietary platform automatically generates social media promotions that you can share with your followers. [FRANCINE-SUMMER] RBmedia, 8400 Corporate Drive, Landover, MD 20785, USA Manage preferences<https://hs-3812525.s.hubspotemail.net/hs/preferences-center/en/page?data=W2nXS-N30h-zKW2-dWzB2xNBxbW2F-82T2KBNW4W2MPs7J1X9ht1W2r4QVd2sL2wdW3LW13p2My3KcW2w166j1XqdrNW2y0W0P32F7yhW3R0bGM3XGmGyW1Xv22r32sw0RW21nPsQ2YshXBW2vK0t3218mtBW2x-lfN1S3zx-W2-tpr4233_RhW2y1Lny2WKG_JW3SHxZ_4tzYCQW4fNLPl2y3lRWW41zBZN2-vBJtW4rDhj12FD3hqW1-YT-n3NF0nTW23ptYX4tn_SfW3XX5M91Zb0l7W4hgzgb2WHcD7W3zbt7L2YykKsW4kFKTd3_F0HSW3SJmpm3V--sNW36fgKY348vQ0W4mpGQ42vK2GYW1Qw16Q2KTkb-W1Lg6T430zCCvW23l-XP3LMTK7W3LVzSn4m8NZxW2w1xlz2qW1sXW2CX1zK3P0SJKW2MLW3K1LnMZKW1N5by81QcClhW1_4p5721hkR7W3Xxggm2Tt8_0W2KRLqq2Wv-fLW4rq3ht4t87kkW3CgjGC1_dDYgW4rxKTN3LW2vlW4hvyKF2vz722W3g7xqm3SCRgzW1VtRv02PPH4XW2r5C5x3P5Xm50&utm_campaign=ASMPpromosends&utm_source=hs_automation&utm_medium=email&utm_content=356120441&_hsenc=p2ANqtz-998VaMGOy2EgYMyzEARBzVjLm56lWL32Jl_C-GZHC_I2r1Itgn-U0uCBBwUiVXqBHiKV2Rb2KDcYfWTvCY3Zt27w_0SA&_hsmi=356120441> _______________________________________________ INDOLOGY mailing list [email protected] https://list.indology.info/mailman/listinfo/indology
_______________________________________________ INDOLOGY mailing list [email protected] https://list.indology.info/mailman/listinfo/indology
