To me that seems like a great argument in favour of the proposal. If you'll
want all variables to be imported (which in this case makes completely
sense), then `fn() {}` or `fn() => {}` is much less verbose and inline with
the mentality to reach for short closures. We reach for short closures to
avoid `use()` and convey that the outer process is intertwined with the
inner process. `fn()` allows to strengthen the concept that there's no real
separation between running SQL stuff in a `callable` that wraps a database
transaction.On Mon, Oct 5, 2020 at 11:57 AM Andreas Leathley <[email protected]> wrote: > On 04.10.20 22:08, Rowan Tommins wrote: > > If we added an opt-in syntax for "capture everything", we might > > instead write this: > > > > $f = function() use (*) { > > $x = $y = $z = null; > > } > > > > Without re-initialising all local variables, we would no longer be > > able to know if they were actually local without looking at the > > surrounding scope for a value that might be captured. I am unconvinced > > by this trade-off of opt-out instead of opt-in. > > > > One use case I've seen proposed is closures which capture a large > > number of variables; I would be interested to see an example where > > this is the case and is not a "code smell" in the same way as > > requiring a large number of parameters. > > Something like "use (*)" seems like a great enhancement to me. I often > use a wrapper function for SQL transactions, something like: > > ```php > public function update(int $numberId, int $addressId, bool $isMainNumber > = false): void > { > $this->transaction->run(function () use ($numberId, $addressId, > $isMainNumber): void { > // Do all SQL queries for the update > }); > } > > ``` > > In these cases there is a lot of redundancy because of having to import > the variables, and if a variable is added, it has to be added in two > places in a slightly different way. The following would be much nicer: > > ```php > public function update(int $numberId, int $addressId, bool $isMainNumber > = false): void > { > $this->transaction->run(function () use (*): void { > // Do all SQL queries for the update > }); > } > > ``` > > This would also increase code readability. > > -- > PHP Internals - PHP Runtime Development Mailing List > To unsubscribe, visit: https://www.php.net/unsub.php > > -- Marco Aurélio Deleu
