Wow! Yess please. My mail yesterday crossed yours, I guess (thanks Claude
for answering)
asking for almost the same:
myClass::$normalProperty::name
So I would like to add my thoughts to your proposal.
I prefer a magic constant like `::name` instead of a function call as it
can be used in a wider scope; for example as a parameter in an Attribute.
My arguments from yesterday:
> 'Directly' accessing properties and methods of the class as a parameter
> in an Attribute is not really possible.
> You can do that for a class with: \path\to\MyClass::class, but for
> properties or methods you have to use strings, without recognition in
> editors.
>
> It would be so nice if more items in php could be accessed with a
> magic constant as you can do with ::class.
> With magic constant an editor could recognize it and it limits typos
> etc. and it provides the developer with a list of the properties/methods in
> scope.
>
>
Some examples from my mail yesterday for using in attributes:
abstract class SaveFactoryAbstract {
use ObjectBuilderTrait;
#[ResetValue]
protected bool $isSaved = false;
#[InitObject] // tells the builder to initialize this property with the
latest specs provided by (other) attributes
#[ResetObject]
protected ?SaveInterface $oSave = null;
public function __construct(){
$this->buildMe(); // provided by the trait
}
}
With a magic constant you could do:
#[UseClass(static::$oSave::name, ImageSave::class)] // using static for
normal property?
#[ResetValue($this->isSaved::name, default: true)] // or using $this ??
class ImageSaveFactory extends SaveFactoryAbstract {
// negative side-effect: empty classes.....
}
>From my mail yesterday:
This could also extend possibilities with/for variable variables....
Like:
$this->myProp::name
myClass::$staticProp::name
A potential difficulty is: how to access normal properties/methods....
Maybe just as if they are static?
Like parent::normalMethod() is working....
A normal property or method cannot have the same name as its static partner
(sadly) so internally I hope it is not a problem.
outside scope:
myClass::$staticProperty::name
myClass::$normalProperty::name
myClass::normalMethod::name
inside scope:
static::$normalProperty::name
self::$normalProperty::name // I do not know if 'self::' adds anything for
this purpose, except for private properties/methods maybe
inside class/object:
$this->normalProperty::name
$this->normalMethod::name
$this::$staticProperty::name
Greetz, Lydia
P.S. I hope the spacing in de code-example is working now.
Op za 13 mei 2023 om 09:27 schreef Robert Landers <[email protected]
>:
>
> Hello Internals,
>
> It is with much trepidation and excitement that I'd like to announce
> the `nameof` RFC (https://wiki.php.net/rfc/nameof). It has changed
> quite a bit in the last couple of days, so if you haven't seen the
> latest draft, please check it out.
>
> Essentially, it allows using `nameof()` anywhere a string can be used,
> even in static contexts. From a developer's perspective, it is a
> string and from the engine's perspective, it is also mostly a string
> (depending on how deep we want to go on error checking -- see the
> RFC).
>
> If anything is unclear or if I missed something, please let me know.
>
> Robert Landers
> Software Engineer
> Utrecht NL
>
> --
> PHP Internals - PHP Runtime Development Mailing List
> To unsubscribe, visit: https://www.php.net/unsub.php
>
