On Wed, Nov 11, 2026, at 8:46 AM, Larry Garfield wrote:

>> «A return statement inside the BODY will return from the function the 
>> code is currently executing in. A finally block in the generator 
>> context manager will still be executed, but otherwise control returns 
>> to the function's caller.»
>> This is also hard to get for me.
>> Can you detail what this would output:
>> function context(): \Generator {
>>   echo "A\n";
>>   yield "B";
>>   echo "C\n";
>>   return "D";
>> }
>> var_dump(
>>   using (context() => $c) {
>>     echo "E\n";
>>     return "F";
>>   }
>> );
>
> I believe (without actually running it) that would output:
>
> A
> E
>
> The return "F" terminates the function that the var_dump()/using() 
> construct is in.  The generator is discarded without ever reaching its 
> end, so the generator's return statement is never reached.
>
> That said, you have brought up an interesting question, I have no idea 
> what happens when you var_dump() a compound expression like this that 
> returns.  Something for Arnaud to write tests for. 0:-)
>
> --Larry Garfield

Actually I'm wrong.  I checked with Arnaud, and it will print A E C.

When you return from the CM block, the generator is first resumed so that it 
gets a chance to do its cleanup, in this case printing C.  When it completes, 
then the function return happens.  The var_dump() is never called, because the 
function returned before that happened.

I have reworded the RFC a bit to make that clearer.  Thanks for calling it out.

--Larry Garfield

Reply via email to