June,
I am confused. Are we schedule driven or feature driven? I am being sent two messages regarding what must be in the release and the date that it must be released. As very few of the contributors do not report to me, I really can only drive to schedule (and cut features) or features (and wait until we meet quality standards), not both. My current priorities are quality then features. With these priorities, as Thiago and I have said it will be done when it is done. Pat From: iotivity-dev-bounces at lists.iotivity.org [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of ??? Sent: Tuesday, April 14, 2015 7:51 AM To: ???; Keany, Bernie; ???; iotivity-dev at lists.iotivity.org; Skarpness, Mark Subject: Re: [dev] Schedule for IoTivity v0.9.1 Release Pat, Could you feedback to BT/BLE review complete by 4/20, so that we can release 0.9.1-RC2? We need a exact schedule urgently, so that we can plan 0.9.1 regarding - if 4/27 is possible - if not, when it will be possible, - what features to be supported if we release 0.9.1 on 4/27 as schedule driven - judging the purpose of 0.9.1 Regards June ------------- 4/15 Release Iotivity Official Q/A Version IoTivity - Tag Name: 0.9.1-RC1 - CA merged version - Need to all Q/A issues 4/17 Complete merge of Android API 4/20 IoTivity v0.9.1_RC1 Test Report 4/21 Release IoTiviy 0.9.1-RC2 version, incldue followings - Tag Name: 0.9.1-RC2 - Andorid API - BT/BLE should be completed 4/24 Q/A Exit (Need consent between Q/A & Dev) 4/27 Web Site Open June Yong Young Principal Engineer IoT Solution Lab. | Web & Convergence Team Software R&D Center, Samsung Electronics Co.,Ltd. T: +82-31-301-6107, M: +82-10-9530-6107 E-mail :juney at samsung.com ------- Original Message ------- Sender : ???<juney at samsung.com <mailto:juney at samsung.com> > S6(??)/??/IoT Solution Lab(S/W??)/???? Date : 2015-04-14 19:03 (GMT+09:00) Title : Re: [dev] Schedule for IoTivity v0.9.1 Release Hi Bernie, Junmo?s schedule is not new one. The schedule below & in the attached mail was shared on 3/24 and discussion has been on-going. And actually April release as Spec vA compliant release was reported to BoD at the OIC OSWG F2F meeting. IoTivity QA release was supposed to start from 4/6, but it is being delayed by almost 2 weeks. We need to get excat schedule to complete Android API, so that we can make a plan for 0.9.1 release. So, I?d like you to discuss with Uze and Junmo and find out when Android API review can be completed. Regards June ------------ - Schedule . 4/6, entry to QA as the official release . 4/24, exit from QA . 4/27, Website Open . Targetting 3 times release to QA before open, 3 days test required per each QA turn . Snapshot release to be made on master branch (not creating release branch) - Main features . Merge CA(connectivity Abstraction) branch onto one master branch . BT/BLE Support, Noti. Manager, Android API (Belkin Plugin, Server) . Scheduled/Recursive Group Action, Secure Bootstrapping, . Spec vA Compliant Pre-Release . No OIC Spec. Conformance Test - QA . Need Full QA test although revision release is to run basic TCs because there lots of changes since 0.9.0 . Refer to QA criteria in the attached(QA_criteria_major release_v1_150313.pptx) : not finalized, still under discussion among IoTivity member company QA teams. June Yong Young Principal Engineer Web & Convergence Team, Software R&D Center Samsung Electronics Co.,Ltd. T: +82-31-301-6107, M: +82-10-9530-6107 E-mail :juney at samsung.com -----Original Message----- From: iotivity-dev-bounces at lists.iotivity.org <mailto:iotivity-dev-bounces at lists.iotivity.org> [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Keany, Bernie Sent: Tuesday, April 14, 2015 10:12 AM To: junmo2.yang at samsung.com <mailto:junmo2.yang at samsung.com> ; iotivity-dev at lists.iotivity.org <mailto:iotivity-dev at lists.iotivity.org> Subject: Re: [dev] Schedule for IoTivity v0.9.1 Release Hello Junmo If this schedule has ever been shared I have never seen it and it is contrary to any timeline that I have presented either at the Face-to-Face in Santa Clara or in OSWG or DCTG calls since the beginning of the year. Starting with the Android API .. As I?ve reported the Android API is on it?s own branch which has been based on the Master branch, over the course of 0.9.0 we?ve pulled changes committed into Master out to the Android API. We have never been able to rebase against the CA branch as until very recently the CA branch would not build for Android. In fact, even today after the merge we?re still not able to build Master for Android (our developers will send an output log shortly as the build limitation is in the connectivity directory). Once the have a stable Master branch that builds for Android we can integrated the Android API branch into Master this is about 13K lines of code including unit tests, samples and the Java API and JNI implementation. This process should take about a week and then we will be ready to push the code for review to the Master Branch. Depending on how long the review takes if the decision is to hold the 0.9.1 release for the Android API then testing will want to verify the resulting base and a release can be done. Alternatively you can release 0.9.1 without the Android API and it can be included in 0.9.2 the PPRTG can make a recommendation on the best course of action. The BT/BLE feature you?ve mentioned is not clear, is it intended to be the Linux capability for the OIC GATT Service Profile? If it is then there are two clarifications we need to consider. The code for the OIC GATT service profile that we shared in the DCTG some weeks ago should be code complete by the end of April and then it could be pushed for review. The implementation is not complete yet but is will be a significant amount of code and will need careful review. The second and more important point is that the Linux implementation would not be interoperable with the Android or Tizen versions that are part of Master today. The issues about the differences in the protocol specification have been documented and discussed in DCTG calls but there has been no commitment for the protocol in the Android and Tizen implementations to be modified to match the specification and implementation of the Linux capability. In summary, the dates are mentioned in schedule that appears below are not achievable, the likely dates would be: Android-API push for review April 22nd assuming the build for Android issues are fixed today or tomorrow. OIC GATT Service Profile for Linux would push for review the week of the April 27th. Availability for release would be dependent on the review process for both components. Please let me know if you have any questions. Bernie Keany Principal Engineer OIC Development Engineering Team, Open Source Technology Center. From: ??? < <mailto:junmo2.yang at samsung.com%3cmailto:junmo2.yang at samsung.com> junmo2.yang at samsung.com<mailto:[email protected]>> Reply-To: " <mailto:junmo2.yang at samsung.com%3cmailto:junmo2.yang at samsung.com%3e> junmo2.yang at samsung.com<mailto:junmo2.yang at samsung.com>" < <mailto:junmo2.yang at samsung.com%3cmailto:junmo2.yang at samsung.com> junmo2.yang at samsung.com<mailto:junmo2.yang at samsung.com>> Date: Sunday, April 12, 2015 at 11:24 PM To: " <mailto:iotivity-dev at lists.iotivity.org%3cmailto:iotivity-dev at lists.iotivity.org%3e> iotivity-dev at lists.iotivity.org<mailto:iotivity-dev at lists.iotivity.org>" < <mailto:iotivity-dev at lists.iotivity.org%3cmailto:iotivity-dev at lists.iotivity.org> iotivity-dev at lists.iotivity.org<mailto:iotivity-dev at lists.iotivity.org>> Subject: [dev] Schedule for IoTivity v0.9.1 Release Dear IoTivity Dev. Members, I'd like to kindly remind the schedlue of Iotivity v0.9.1. If anyone has any comment or suggestion, please share it. 4/15 Release Iotivity Official Q/A Version IoTivity - Tag Name: 0.9.1-RC1 - CA merged version - Need to all Q/A issues 4/17 Complete merge of Android API 4/20 IoTivity v0.9.1_RC1 Test Report 4/21 Release IoTiviy 0.9.1-RC2 version, incldue followings - Tag Name: 0.9.1-RC2 - Andorid API - BT/BLE should be completed 4/24 Q/A Exit (Need consent between Q/A & Dev) 4/27 Web Site Open BR, - Junmo Yang ??? (Junmo Yang, Ph.D.) Principal Engineer IoT Solution Lab./Web & Convergence Team Software R&D Center, Samsung Electronics Co.,Ltd. Mobile: +82-10-7260-7032 E-mail: <mailto:junmo2.yang at samsung.com%3cmailto:junmo2.yang at samsung.com> junmo2.yang at samsung.com<mailto:junmo2.yang at samsung.com> [cid:MKNRCZHWKC3T at namo.co.kr] -------Original Message-------- Sent: "JuneYong Young" <juney at samsung.com <mailto:juney at samsung.com> > Date: Tue, 24 Mar 2015 19:29:32 +0900 Subject: Re: [dev] [Request for feedback] IoTivity 0.9.1 Release Schedule & Feature One thing important is missing in blue below. IoTivity 0.9.1 should be Spec vA Compliant Pre-release, so please check if anything important that can not be released and let us know Hi George, Felix, I'm still waiting for your feedback about the QA release schedule and features to be added. Would you please check this out? Hi JunMo,(He is in Samsung release management function) Whould you please gather the feature list from George and Felix? Regards June June Yong Young Principal Engineer IoT Solution Lab. | Web & Convergence Team Software R&D Center, Samsung Electronics Co.,Ltd. T: +82-31-301-6107, M: +82-10-9530-6107 E-mail :juney at samsung.com ------- Original Message ------- Sender : ???<juney at samsung.com <mailto:juney at samsung.com> > S6(??)/??/IoT Solution Lab(S/W??)/???? Date : 2015-03-17 13:56 (GMT+09:00) Title : [dev] [Request for feedback] IoTivity 0.9.1 Release Schedule & Feature Dear IoTivity Members This is the announcement for IoTivity 0.9.1 release schedule in April. (IoTivity 1.0.0 is to be released as full compliant of the Spec in around Sep./Oct. timeframe according the direction of BoD.) Please let us know your opinion about the schedule and confirm the features to be applied in April release. - Schedule . 4/6, entry to QA as the official release . 4/24, exit from QA . 4/27, Website Open . Targetting 3 times release to QA before open, 3 days test required per each QA turn . Snapshot release to be made on master branch (not creating release branch) - Main features . Merge CA(connectivity Abstraction) branch onto one master branch . BT/BLE Support, Noti. Manager, Android API (Belkin Plugin, Server) . Scheduled/Recursive Group Action, Secure Bootstrapping, . Spec vA Compliant Pre-Release . No OIC Spec. Conformance Test - QA . Need Full QA test although revision release is to run basic TCs because there lots of changes since 0.9.0 . Refer to QA criteria in the attached(QA_criteria_major release_v1_150313.pptx) : not finalized, still under discussion among IoTivity member company QA teams. - Featues to be added . Please let us all know any additional features which are not addressed in the exel file.(IoTivity_Features_0.9.0_0.9.1_eng_150313.xlsx) George, Felix, Please refer to the feaures sorted out in the exel file and please feedback the features to be added from your side for 0.9.1. Regards June Features on V0.9.0 vs V0.9.1 Features V0.9.0 V0.9.1 Ownership Feature Detail Remark 12-30 4-27 ???? Company Notification Manager Lite Device Resource Discovery ? N Y ? Samsung Formation of the Virtual Resource for Lite Device N Y ? Samsung Resource proxy instead of Lite Device using Virtual Resource N Y ? Samsung Soft Sensor Manager ?Physical Sensor Data Listening ? Y Y ? Samsung Developing template for Sensor Fusion as a library andDeploying/Executing the library ? Y Y ? Samsung Query-based Sensor Data Request ? Y Y ? Samsung Reference soft sensors ? Y Y ? Samsung ? Bridging in a local network using Pluggable Protocols Converters ? Y Y ? Samsung Protocol Plugin C/C++ and Java Support for Multi Platforms - Linux, Android, Tizen ? N Y ? Samsung Hue Plugin with JAVA (Android only) - On/Off, Change Color, Dimming ? N Y ? Samsung MQTT Plugin with C/C++ - FAN On/Off ? Y Y ? Samsung Gear Plugin with Java(Android only) - Notification to Gear - User Activity Event Receiving from Gear ? Y Y ? Samsung Belkin Wemo Plugin with Java(Android only) - Motion Sensor, Switch On/Off ? N Y ? Samsung Things Manager Find appropriate resources for the specific group ? Y Y ? Samsung Find/Create/Delete a group ? Y Y ? Samsung Join/Leave ? Y Y ? Samsung Let the other devices to join the specific group ? Y Y ? Samsung Get the information of all groups ? Y Y ? Samsung Check presence information of group (member resource's connectivity/resource change) ? Y Y ? Samsung Take a single action on a group to affect all member resources (Group Action using ActionSet) ? Y Y ? Samsung CRUD function for ActionSet ? Y Y ? Samsung Send configuration/diagnostics command to multiple things ? Y Y ? Samsung Get the parameter list of configuration feature ? Y Y ? Samsung Get the functionality list of diagnostics feature ? Y Y ? Samsung Control Manager Provides framework and services to implement a Controller with Smart Home Data Model ? Y Y ? Samsung Provides RESTful Resource Request/Response handler with Device Discovery and Subscription/Notification Manager ? Y Y ? Samsung Provides framework and services to implement a Controlee ? Y Y ? Samsung Provides RESTful Resource request Handler to perform the action requested by the Controllers ? Y Y ? Samsung Provides discovery of the devices and resources a device hosts ? Y Y ? Samsung Handles subscription requests from the Controllers ? Y Y ? Samsung Provides HTTP based REST framework for Control Manager ? Y Y ? Samsung Android Support Supports client side Java APIs for Android ? Y Y ? Intel Requires Android NDK version 10 or later ? Y Y ? Intel Requires Android SDK API level 19 ? Y Y ? Intel Sample applications demonstrate Java SDK ? Y Y ? Intel Android API refactoring and completion (Server API Support) ? N Y ? Intel/Samsung Security Adds TLS_ECDH_anon_WITH_AES_128_CBC_SHA cipher suite in tinyDTLS for unauthenticated security configuration only ? ? Y ? Samsung Authentication method during security configuration (by checking confirm code in the device which has display) ? ? Y ? Samsung Security Configuration(BootStrapping) API for admin device & sample ? ? Y ? Samsung Security Resource Manager ? ? TBD ? Intel/Samsung Connectivity Abstraction This feature integrates the resource model (aka Resource Introspection - RI) and Connectivity Abstraction (CA) layers. ? Y Y ? Intel The CA layer provides abstraction to the RI layer from adaptors and transport protocols. This release showcases the integration of RI and CA layers over multiple heterogeneous adaptors (Wi-Fi and Ethernet). ? Y Y ? Samsung Features existing with RI and CA integration- Discovery (multicast and unicast), GET, PUT, POST, DELETE and Observe and Active Discovery (aka presence). ? Y Y ? Samsung Supports both secure and non-secure resources. ? Y Y ? Samsung The user has the option to include/exclude the CA layer using compiler flag CA_INT. In the current code by default the CA_INT compiler flag is included and hence the CA layer is included. ? Y Y ? Intel Some of the C/C++ APIs have changed for CA integration. These changes are included in the CA_INT flag in the header files. ? Y Y ? Intel During resource discovery it is possible for the same resource to be discovered on multiple adaptors. To resolve this a Server Identifier (SID) is included in the resource discovery response. ? Y Y ? Intel The discovery response also includes the adaptor type on which the resource was discovered (Ethernet, Wi-Fi, etc) and this information is passed to the application. If the same resource is reachable via multiple adaptors, i.e. it has been discovered on multiple connectivity types, the application must specify which interface to use for subsequent GET/PUT/POST/DELETE/observe operations. ? Y Y ? Samsung Unicast discovery uses port 5683; multicast discovery uses port 5298 ? Y Y ? Samsung Sample application demonstrating CA integration: - ocserver and occlient in C sample. - simpleserver and simpleclient C++ sample. - presenceserver C31and presenceclient C++ sample. ? Y Y ? Samsung BT/BLE Support ? N Y ? Samsung ?Support for HIGH QoS. ? N Y ? Samsung slow response. ? N Y ? Samsung Device discovery works on a single adaptor. ? N Y ? Samsung Only unicast presence supported. ? N Y ? Samsung CA integration has been tested only on Ubuntu. ? N Y ? Samsung Discovery and Connectivity CoAP model- IoTvity supports information exchange and control based on the messaging/CoAP model. IoTivity also manages radio connections between devices (Wi-Fi, LAN) and across any available transport, whether it?s device-to-device or across the same network ? ? ? ? Intel Discovery- This feature provides discovery mechanisms for finding resources in proximity. ? ? ? ? Intel Device Discovery- This feature provides a mechanism to find devices based on specific device-level attributes. ? ? ? ? Intel Active Discovery- This feature provides presence notifications based on a) a resource coming online or b) a change in a resource's properties or c) a resource going offline. It allows a client to subscribe/unsubscribe (unicast or multicast) for presence notifications. ? ? ? ? Intel Resource Management Resource model operations- IoTivity supports fundamental resource model based operations such as GET, PUT, POST, DELETE apart from Observations and its notifications. Observe notifications can be sent to all clients or to a specific set of clients. ? ? ? ? Intel Entity Handler support- This allows a server app developer to handle incoming client requests and respond after processing the requests. A default device entity handler is also supported to handle a request that does not match the existing registered resource. ? ? ? ? Intel Header Options support- This feature allows the client to send custom header options to the server and vice-versa. ? ? ? ? Intel QoS support- This feature allows the app developer to choose the quality of service which currently translates to non-confirmable (LOW_QoS) and confirmable (HIGH_QoS) in CoAP. ? ? ? ? Intel SDK- The SDK abstracts all the OS APIs for radio connections into simpler APIs. SDK provides APIs for platform initialization (Client/Server/Client-Server mode in In-Proc model), discovery of resources, discovery of devices, registration/creation of resources and resource model operations. ? ? ? ? Intel Collection- This feature provides a root resource to point to other resources. This features includes operations on default, linklist and batch interfaces on a collection resource. ? ? ? ? Intel JSON format- IoTivity uses JSON data format with JSON serialization and de-serialization in C++ SDK layer. ? ? ? ? Intel Slow response- This feature allows a server application to indicate 'slow response' to a client on an incoming request. This enables the server process the request, then send a response at a later time. ? ? ? ? Intel Security- This feature provides security that allows app developers to create secure resources and communicate with resources in a secured channel. ? ? ? ? Intel Tizen Support IoTivity project build supported on Tizen 2.3 and 3.0 (both on IA and ARM version) ? ? ? ? Intel No new specific APIs for Tizen; Tizen development support and build process provided in "Readme.scons.txt" ? ? ? ? Intel Yocto Support meta-oic software layer for Yocto separately hosted on git.yoctoproject.org. ? ? ? ? Intel Contains recipes to build the IoTivity framework and SDK for Yocto based embedded targets. ? ? ? ? Intel Can utilize Yocto provisioned infrastructure to construct target toolchains to cross-compile IoTivity applications for that target. ? ? ? ? Intel Tested successfully on Intel Edison and MinnowBoard MAX platforms. ? ? ? ? Intel Currently supports the resource layer (runtimes and applications) of the IoTivity stack. ? ? ? ? Intel OICSensorBoard provides sample IoTivity application for the Intel Edison Platform. ? ? ? ? Intel Demonstrates IoTivity Server capabilities on the Edison through the integration of an add-on breadboard that hosts temperature, ambient light and LED resources. ? ? ? ? Intel Client-server functionality successfully tested by building server using Yocto toolchain for Edison and client for Ubuntu. ? ? ? ? Intel Fully documented connection diagram of sensors to Edison, build configuration, supported IoTivity interfaces and methods, and client/server. ? ? ? ? Intel Scons Support SCons provides cross-platform build tool. ? ? ? ? Intel IoTivity project can be built on Linux, Windows, MAC OSX for various OS(Linux, Tizen, Android, Arduino, Windos, MAC OSX, iOS). SCons readme file available at parent folder 'iotivity'. ? ? ? ? Intel June Yong Young Principal Engineer IoT Solution Lab. | Web & Convergence Team Software R&D Center, Samsung Electronics Co.,Ltd. T: +82-31-301-6107, M: +82-10-9530-6107 E-mail :juney at samsung.com <http://ext.samsung.net/mailcheck/SeenTimeChecker?do=d083a0c0528fae522cfd0bc800463dcdac3e5864f9d7d54bc13f49ee879cb6cf65afe93a9dd766927f71ac62d5c138b2195f377979c7bbe51b20909a04efd4d2748cfe1d4e847419cf878f9a26ce15a0> -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: <http://lists.iotivity.org/pipermail/iotivity-dev/attachments/20150414/11fd0f66/attachment.html> -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: image001.gif Type: image/gif Size: 13168 bytes Desc: not available URL: <http://lists.iotivity.org/pipermail/iotivity-dev/attachments/20150414/11fd0f66/attachment.gif> -------------- next part -------------- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: smime.p7s Type: application/pkcs7-signature Size: 7198 bytes Desc: not available URL: <http://lists.iotivity.org/pipermail/iotivity-dev/attachments/20150414/11fd0f66/attachment.p7s>
