Hi, I see two possibilities how Comarch can help you:
1. We can fix the IoTivity code 2. We can add some temporary workaround in the CTT for this IUT issue (so CTT will be able to parse such incorrect message) Jacek From: ??? (Uze Choi) [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, April 18, 2017 2:02 AM To: iotivity-dev at lists.iotivity.org Cc: '???' <j3s3h3.jin at samsung.com>; 'Jacek Hryszkiewicz' <jacek.hryszkiewicz at comarch.com>; 'Mitch Kettrick' <cpm at openconnectivity.org> Subject: RE: IoTivity 1.3-rel vs CTT 1.5.4 - Test Results Hello, Regarding discovery logic, are there any other contributor? This problem prevents next step continue. We cannot make any progress due to this blocker. Ziran is busy in versioning related patch as of now. Contribution will be very welcomed BR, Uze Choi From: ??? (Uze Choi) [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, April 14, 2017 3:55 PM To: Habib Virji (habib.virji at samsung.com <mailto:habib.virji at samsung.com> ); 'Ziran Sun'; 'i.mushfiq at samsung.com' Cc: 'nathan.heldt-sheller at intel.com'; 'Daniel.Mihai at microsoft.com'; 'vkandalla at graniteriverlabs.com'; 'lab_mgr at openconnectivity.org'; 'Towhidul Islam'; 'Mark Trayer'; '???'; 'ofer at tekoia.com'; 'richard.a.bardini at intel.com'; '????'; 'b.scriber at cablelabs.com'; 'dbartolome at at4wireless.com'; '???'; 'david.r.kaufman at honeywell.com'; 'todd.malsbary at intel.com'; 'srikguru at microsoft.com'; '???'; 'ed.agis at intel.com'; 'joseph.l.morrow at intel.com'; '???'; 'craig at ecaspia.com'; 'Jacek Hryszkiewicz'; 'Mitch Kettrick' Subject: RE: IoTivity 1.3-rel vs CTT 1.5.4 - Test Results Ziran/Habib, Could you check the discovery response payload applying the OCF1.0 spec? BR, Uze Choi From: Jacek Hryszkiewicz [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, April 14, 2017 3:31 PM To: 'Mitch Kettrick'; 'Ziran Sun'; i.mushfiq at samsung.com <mailto:i.mushfiq at samsung.com> Cc: nathan.heldt-sheller at intel.com <mailto:nathan.heldt-sheller at intel.com> ; Daniel.Mihai at microsoft.com <mailto:Daniel.Mihai at microsoft.com> ; vkandalla at graniteriverlabs.com <mailto:vkandalla at graniteriverlabs.com> ; lab_mgr at openconnectivity.org <mailto:lab_mgr at openconnectivity.org> ; 'Towhidul Islam'; 'Mark Trayer'; '???'; '???'; ofer at tekoia.com <mailto:ofer at tekoia.com> ; richard.a.bardini at intel.com <mailto:richard.a.bardini at intel.com> ; '????'; b.scriber at cablelabs.com <mailto:b.scriber at cablelabs.com> ; dbartolome at at4wireless.com <mailto:dbartolome at at4wireless.com> ; '???'; david.r.kaufman at honeywell.com <mailto:david.r.kaufman at honeywell.com> ; todd.malsbary at intel.com <mailto:todd.malsbary at intel.com> ; wovander at cisco.com <mailto:wovander at cisco.com> ; srikguru at microsoft.com <mailto:srikguru at microsoft.com> ; '???'; ed.agis at intel.com <mailto:ed.agis at intel.com> ; '???'; joseph.l.morrow at intel.com <mailto:joseph.l.morrow at intel.com> ; '???'; craig at ecaspia.com <mailto:craig at ecaspia.com> Subject: RE: IoTivity 1.3-rel vs CTT 1.5.4 - Test Results Hi, Issue 1: This is IUT issue. CTT sends RETIREVE request for oic/res with the interface oic.if.baseline. Proper response for such request is an array of objects (see schema and RAML) while here IUT responds with an object: {"n":"Vendor Smart Home AirCon Device","di":"6a757374-776f-726b-4465-765575696430","rt":["oic.wk.res"],"if":["oic.if.ll","oic.if.baseline"],"links":[{"href":"/oic/sec/doxm","anchor":"ocf://6a757374-776f-726b-4465-765575696430","rt":["oic.r.doxm"],"if":["oic.if.baseline"],"p":{"bm":1},"eps":[{"ep":"coap://192.168.56.101:47103","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://192.168.56.101:53909","pri":1},{"ep":"coap://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1}]},{"href":"/oic/sec/pstat","anchor":"ocf://6a757374-776f-726b-4465-765575696430","rt":["oic.r.pstat"],"if":["oic.if.baseline"],"p":{"bm":1},"eps":[{"ep":"coap://192.168.56.101:47103","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://192.168.56.101:53909","pri":1},{"ep":"coap://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1}]},{"href":"/oic/d","anchor":"ocf://6a757374-776f-726b-4465-765575696430","rt":["oic.wk.d","oic.d.airconditioner"],"if":["oic.if.baseline","oic.if.r"],"p":{"bm":1},"eps":[{"ep":"coap://192.168.56.101:47103","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://192.168.56.101:53909","pri":1},{"ep":"coap://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1}]},{"href":"/oic/p","anchor":"ocf://6a757374-776f-726b-4465-765575696430","rt":["oic.wk.p"],"if":["oic.if.baseline","oic.if.r"],"p":{"bm":1},"eps":[{"ep":"coap://192.168.56.101:47103","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://192.168.56.101:53909","pri":1},{"ep":"coap://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1}]},{"href":"/oic/introspection","anchor":"ocf://6a757374-776f-726b-4465-765575696430","rt":["oic.wk.introspection"],"if":["oic.if.baseline","oic.if.r"],"p":{"bm":1},"eps":[{"ep":"coap://192.168.56.101:47103","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://192.168.56.101:53909","pri":1},{"ep":"coap://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1}]},{"href":"/BinarySwitchResURI","anchor":"ocf://6a757374-776f-726b-4465-765575696430","rt":["oic.r.switch.binary"],"if":["oic.if.baseline","oic.if.a"],"p":{"bm":3},"eps":[{"ep":"coap://192.168.56.101:47103","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://192.168.56.101:53909","pri":1},{"ep":"coap://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1}]},{"href":"/TemperatureResURI","anchor":"ocf://6a757374-776f-726b-4465-765575696430","rt":["oic.r.temperature"],"if":["oic.if.baseline","oic.if.a"],"p":{"bm":3},"eps":[{"ep":"coap://192.168.56.101:47103","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://192.168.56.101:53909","pri":1},{"ep":"coap://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1}]},{"href":"/AirFlowResURI","anchor":"ocf://6a757374-776f-726b-4465-765575696430","rt":["oic.r.airflow"],"if":["oic.if.baseline","oic.if.a"],"p":{"bm":3},"eps":[{"ep":"coap://192.168.56.101:47103","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://192.168.56.101:53909","pri":1},{"ep":"coap://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1}]},{"href":"/Vendor/AirConditioner/TimerClock","anchor":"ocf://6a757374-776f-726b-4465-765575696430","rt":["x.com.vendor.timer"],"if":["oic.if.baseline","oic.if.a"],"p":{"bm":1},"eps":[{"ep":"coap://192.168.56.101:47103","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://192.168.56.101:53909","pri":1},{"ep":"coap://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1}]},{"href":"/Vendor/AirConditioner/Swinger","anchor":"ocf://6a757374-776f-726b-4465-765575696430","rt":["x.com.vendor.swing"],"if":["oic.if.baseline","oic.if.a"],"p":{"bm":1},"eps":[{"ep":"coap://192.168.56.101:47103","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://192.168.56.101:53909","pri":1},{"ep":"coap://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1}]},{"href":"/vendor/aircon/collection/extra","anchor":"ocf://6a757374-776f-726b-4465-765575696430","rt":["oic.wk.col","x.com.vendor.aircon.collection.extra"],"if":["oic.if.baseline","oic.if.ll","oic.if.b"],"p":{"bm":1},"eps":[{"ep":"coap://192.168.56.101:47103","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://192.168.56.101:53909","pri":1},{"ep":"coap://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1}]},{"href":"/vendor/aircon/collection","anchor":"ocf://6a757374-776f-726b-4465-765575696430","rt":["oic.wk.col","x.com.vendor.aircon.collection"],"if":["oic.if.baseline","oic.if.ll","oic.if.b"],"p":{"bm":1},"eps":[{"ep":"coap://192.168.56.101:47103","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://192.168.56.101:53909","pri":1},{"ep":"coap://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1},{"ep":"coaps://[fe80::36bc:ba82:adf0:c83a]:0","pri":1}]}]} Best Regards, Jacek Hryszkiewicz From: Mitch Kettrick [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, April 13, 2017 8:03 PM To: 'Ziran Sun' <ziran.sun at samsung.com <mailto:ziran.sun at samsung.com> >; i.mushfiq at samsung.com <mailto:i.mushfiq at samsung.com> ; jacek.hryszkiewicz at comarch.com <mailto:jacek.hryszkiewicz at comarch.com> Cc: nathan.heldt-sheller at intel.com <mailto:nathan.heldt-sheller at intel.com> ; Daniel.Mihai at microsoft.com <mailto:Daniel.Mihai at microsoft.com> ; vkandalla at graniteriverlabs.com <mailto:vkandalla at graniteriverlabs.com> ; lab_mgr at openconnectivity.org <mailto:lab_mgr at openconnectivity.org> ; 'Towhidul Islam' <t.islam at samsung.com <mailto:t.islam at samsung.com> >; 'Mark Trayer' <m.trayer at samsung.com <mailto:m.trayer at samsung.com> >; '???' <jinchoe at samsung.com <mailto:jinchoe at samsung.com> >; '???' <uzchoi at samsung.com <mailto:uzchoi at samsung.com> >; ofer at tekoia.com <mailto:ofer at tekoia.com> ; richard.a.bardini at intel.com <mailto:richard.a.bardini at intel.com> ; '????' <dwarka.dayama at samsung.com <mailto:dwarka.dayama at samsung.com> >; b.scriber at cablelabs.com <mailto:b.scriber at cablelabs.com> ; dbartolome at at4wireless.com <mailto:dbartolome at at4wireless.com> ; '???' <jminl.choi at samsung.com <mailto:jminl.choi at samsung.com> >; david.r.kaufman at honeywell.com <mailto:david.r.kaufman at honeywell.com> ; todd.malsbary at intel.com <mailto:todd.malsbary at intel.com> ; wovander at cisco.com <mailto:wovander at cisco.com> ; srikguru at microsoft.com <mailto:srikguru at microsoft.com> ; '???' <moonki1.hong at samsung.com <mailto:moonki1.hong at samsung.com> >; ed.agis at intel.com <mailto:ed.agis at intel.com> ; '???' <daeken.kwon at samsung.com <mailto:daeken.kwon at samsung.com> >; joseph.l.morrow at intel.com <mailto:joseph.l.morrow at intel.com> ; '???' <j3s3h3.jin at samsung.com <mailto:j3s3h3.jin at samsung.com> >; craig at ecaspia.com <mailto:craig at ecaspia.com> Subject: RE: IoTivity 1.3-rel vs CTT 1.5.4 - Test Results Hi, 1. It looks like several test cases did not run with an exception thrown failure like this: 1.193s 11:56:13 ERROR:?Exception thrown from python script: Failed to run python script from file "C:\Program Files (x86)\OCF Certification Test Tool\Configuration\OCF\TestCases\Resource_CT1_2_6.py" Traceback (most recent ... 1.193s 11:56:13 DEBUG:?continued: ...call last): File "C:\Program Files (x86)\OCF Certification Test Tool\Configuration\OCF\TestCases\Resource_CT1_2_6.py", line 211, in File "C:\Program Files (x86)\OCF Certification Test Tool\Configuration\OCF\TestCases\Resource_CT1_2_6.py", line 138, in run File "C:\Program Files (x86)\OCF Certification Test Tool\Configuration\OCF\TestCasesUtils\CT_Security_Common.py", line 25, in add_aces_for_all_resources File "C:\Program Files (x86)\OCF Certification Test Tool\Configuration\OCF\TestCasesUtils\CT_Common.py", line 159, in get_base_links TypeError: iteration over non-sequence of type NoneType Can you look into this please, Jacek? 2. Regarding the issue with the Endpoint test case, can you confirm what the ACL is on the IUT? We are silent on what ACL/ACE to use in this test case and it's possible that this is what is causing the failures. 3. I also noticed that you're exposing IPv6 Endpoints and none of them are accessible. Does the IUT support IPv6? If not, those Endpoints should not be exposed. No sense in spending too much more time on these logs until the first issue is resolved. Mitch From: Ziran Sun [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Thursday, April 13, 2017 8:49 AM To: i.mushfiq at samsung.com <mailto:i.mushfiq at samsung.com> ; cpm at openconnectivity.org <mailto:cpm at openconnectivity.org> Cc: nathan.heldt-sheller at intel.com <mailto:nathan.heldt-sheller at intel.com> ; Daniel.Mihai at microsoft.com <mailto:Daniel.Mihai at microsoft.com> ; vkandalla at graniteriverlabs.com <mailto:vkandalla at graniteriverlabs.com> ; lab_mgr at openconnectivity.org <mailto:lab_mgr at openconnectivity.org> ; 'Towhidul Islam'; 'Mark Trayer'; '???'; jacek.hryszkiewicz at comarch.com <mailto:jacek.hryszkiewicz at comarch.com> ; '???'; ofer at tekoia.com <mailto:ofer at tekoia.com> ; richard.a.bardini at intel.com <mailto:richard.a.bardini at intel.com> ; '????'; b.scriber at cablelabs.com <mailto:b.scriber at cablelabs.com> ; dbartolome at at4wireless.com <mailto:dbartolome at at4wireless.com> ; '???'; david.r.kaufman at honeywell.com <mailto:david.r.kaufman at honeywell.com> ; todd.malsbary at intel.com <mailto:todd.malsbary at intel.com> ; wovander at cisco.com <mailto:wovander at cisco.com> ; srikguru at microsoft.com <mailto:srikguru at microsoft.com> ; '???'; ed.agis at intel.com <mailto:ed.agis at intel.com> ; '???'; joseph.l.morrow at intel.com <mailto:joseph.l.morrow at intel.com> ; '???'; craig at ecaspia.com <mailto:craig at ecaspia.com> Subject: RE: IoTivity 1.3-rel vs CTT 1.5.4 - Test Results Hi, Just let you know that versioning related patches are not all in yet. They are dependent on a provisioning related patch. We are hoping to have them in ASAP. Best regards, Ziran -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: <http://lists.iotivity.org/pipermail/iotivity-dev/attachments/20170418/57678850/attachment.html>
