From: "Darren Reed" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > In some email I received from Jason Ish, sie wrote: > > Is a dup-to rule with an optional IP address actually supposed to > > rewrite the destination IP of the packet? From reading ipf(5) it sounds > > like it should, but doing a quick test this does not happen. > > > > My question is, if a rule contains 'dup-to rtk0:w.x.y.z' is the IP > > destination supposed to be rewritten or does that just specify the > > next hop as in a 'to rtk0:w.x.y.z' rule? > > No, the IP address is never rewritten. > > Darren
After reading this post I decided to make some new tests with ipf. I replaced my actual rules : pass out quick on fxp0 to fxp1:195.205.159.2 proto tcp from 195.205.159.14 to any pass out quick on fxp0 to fxp1:195.205.159.2 proto udp from 195.205.159.14 to any pass out quick on fxp0 to fxp1:195.205.159.2 proto icmp from 195.205.159.14 to any when 195.205.159.14 is an IP address of the fxp1 interface and 195.205.159.2 is a router IP to something like this: block out quick on fxp0 proto tcp from 195.205.159.14/32 to any block out quick on fxp0 proto udp from 195.205.159.14/32 to any block out quick on fxp0 proto icmp from 195.205.159.14/32 to any pass out quick on fxp0 dup-to fxp1:195.205.159.2 proto tcp from 195.205.159.14/32 to any pass out quick on fxp0 dup-to fxp1:195.205.159.2 proto udp from 195.205.159.14/32 to any pass out quick on fxp0 dup-to fxp1:195.205.159.2 proto icmp from 195.205.159.14/32 to any and this doesn't work too but then I deleted the optional IP address from 'fxp1:195.205.159.2' to just 'fxp1'. And guess what ? Now outgoing packets/datagrams/whatever with source IP 195.205.159.14 are really going back thru the fxp1 interface which is not the default gateway device. And on the other machine I see: 07:07:36.213529 212.33.84.150 > 195.205.159.14: icmp: echo request 07:07:36.213714 195.205.159.14 > 212.33.84.150: icmp: echo reply -- Karol Daniszewski http://net.art.pl/ Net Art
