Hi all,

Setup for this test:
  - hostA the router/firewall [FreeBSD 4.4]
  - hostB linux bridge with ssh server running
  - hostC box on local network

Using IPFilter 3.4.20:

  relevant ipnat rules:
rdr rl0 172.27.40.1/32 port 8022 -> 172.27.40.9 port
22
map rl0 from 172.27.40.0/23 to 172.27.40.9/32 port =
22 -> 0/32 portmap tcp 20000:21000

Telnetting to port 8022 on the router (172.27.40.1)
would redirect successfuly to the linux brigde
(172.27.40.9) and (almost) all is as it should be.Ssh
sessions work.The only thing that shouldn't be
happening is the icmp redirect messages that the
router sends to hostB and hostC.To solve this i tried
to use the "fastroute" option to prevent the kernel
from seeing the packets, alas generating the
redirects.The rules used were:
block in quick on rl0 to rl0 proto tcp from any to
172.27.41.9 port = 22
block in quick on rl0 to rl0 proto tcp from
172.27.40.9 port = 22 to any
This automagically caused the router to reboot.

Using IPFilter 3.4.27:

Same ipf/ipnat rules as before.Telnetting to the
router on port 8022 displays the ssh id string,
however typing random chars, doesn't result in the ssh
server saying "Protocol mismatch" and closing the
connection.It just hangs there.Pings to hostB from the
router don't work anymore, but work from localnet.Same
for telnetting to port 22 on hostB.After trying some
more telnets on router port 8022 from hostC, the
router "hangs".It doesn't accept any new connections
and the console is hung.It does respond to pings, and
(i think, it was 3am when trying this,and i'm not
sure) it is doing nat.

Some of you might wonder why don't I just use a
bouncer on the router and redirect to it.The answer is
this: I don't like packets copied being copied all
over the memory.rl cards are crappy cards and can only
send from special aligned mbufs.And I especially don't
want to add packets being copied to and from kernel
space/user space.

If I forgot to specify something please ask.I'm pretty
tired right now, so I might have forgotten something.

The implicit question was: How do I do the reflector
work?(if possible).I know linux netfilter does it and
it stops the kernel from generating the redirects.

Thanks in advance for any help,

Shock.


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
LAUNCH - Your Yahoo! Music Experience
http://launch.yahoo.com

Reply via email to