On Wed, 22 May 2002 08:37:36 -0700
Cy Schubert - CITS Open Systems Group <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> >     An IPFilter port would help considerably for those who
> > want to upgrade ipf beyond the version that is in the src tree for
> > FreeBSD. For example, it is advantages for me (in my situation) to
> > upgraded ipf to 3.4.27 in FreeBSD-4.5-p4.  While it is trivial to
>                             ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
> That's the issue with the port.  Depending on the release that you're 
> running, the patches may be different, not to mention that I've seen IP 
> Filter problems running on the latest -stable or -current, while it 
> runs nicely on -release.  Of course, whatever I am running at the time 
> is what the port would be based on, making the port possibly available 
> to a subset of FreeBSD IPF users.  In short, there would be an unknown 
> likelihood of this not working on systems that are not the same as mine.
> 
> Additionally, as the port is upgraded, older versions of FreeBSD would 
> not be supported because I would have no way of testing the port 
> install on older versions.  Keeping older versions of the port on a web 
> site might help, however they would become obsolete once a new version 
> of IPF is released.

Cy, I think a port is a great idea. In my case usually the OS 
is a fairly recent 4-STABLE, and a port would get more admins 
using the latest ipf on selected systems, and providing more 
feedback for the FreeBSD community :-)

> 
> How can we mitigate this problem?  Though not a perfect solution, 
> having people willing to test this for me should help.  Other than that 
> this would be a fly-by-the-seat-of-the-pants operation.  Are people 
> willing to live with this?

I am willing to test your port prototypes, and feel that a 
"perfect solution" when using "leading edge" software is a 
noble but rarely attainable goal. The usual disclaimers 
should be made clear, and after that is understood "fly-by-
the-seat-of-the-pants" is easy to live with ;)

Your "unsupported" ipf upgrade procedures for FreeBSD have served 
me well in the past, and the ability to buildworld on a system 
and not lose the ipf upgrade has been very helpful. I have hacked 
together shell scripts in the past to update the ipf bits after a 
cvsup session, but re-installing a port would be even better, 
along with the bonus of an MD5 checksum for the ipf source.


Regards,

Stephen Hilton
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to