- Abstract: "It replaces..." Here "it" seems to refer to "IKE", which
isn't correct; it should refer to "This document". This could be fixed
by e.g. switching the first and second sentence, or changing "it" to
"This document".
- Section 1.2: s/IKE_INFORMATIONAL/INFORMATIONAL/
- Section 1.4, 3rd paragraph: suggest changing "message with no
payloads" and "also contain no payloads" to "empty message" (Section
1.2 says empty message means encrypted payload only, but "no payloads"
sounds a bit different)
- Section 2.21.2: There's a "NOTE FOR WG DISCUSSION" (just FYI so it's
not forgotten there)
- Section 2.23: "port on which this packet was sent": would "port from
which this packet was sent" be clearer?
- Section 2.23, 5th bullet ("The recipient of either..."): the "that
system SHOULD start sending keepalive packets as defined in
[UDPENCAPS]" is a bit redundant; it's repeated two bullets later.
- Section 2.25.1, first paragraph: "..based on the nonces":
suggest adding pointer "(see Section 2.8.1)".
- Section 2.25.1, 2nd paragraph, 1st sentence: suggest
adding pointer "(see Section 1.4.1)"
- Section 2.25.2, "...based on the nonces": suggest adding
pointer "(see Section 2.8.2)".
Best regards,
Pasi
_______________________________________________
IPsec mailing list
IPsec@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ipsec
