"O ye who believe! Take not into your intimacy those outside your ranks:
They will not fail to corrupt you. They only desire your ruin: Rank hatred
has already appeared from their mouths: What their hearts conceal is far
worse. We have made plain to you the Signs, if ye have wisdom."

(Al-Qur'an, 3:118 Aal-E-Imran [The Family of Imran])
*Pair Who Forced Their Muslim Colleague to Eat Bacon Lose Appeal*
**

*Friday, October 10, 2008, 08:00*
*
http://www.thisissuttoncoldfield.co.uk/greatbarr/Pair-forced-Muslim-colleague-eat-bacon-lose-appeal/article-388442-detail/article.html
*
**
*A Kingstanding man who subjected his **'**vulnerable**'** Muslim colleague
to a 10-month bullying campaign saw his appeal against a jail sentence for
racially aggravated harassment thrown out by the Appeal Court this week.*
**
Sean Martin Melaney, 29, of Streatham Grove, along with two other road
maintenance workers, admitted to harassing colleague Amjid Mehmood. All four
worked for a road maintenance firm in Walsall. The three were each sentenced
at Wolverhampton Crown Court in April to three-years imprisonment.

The workmates had bullied Mr Mehmood by:


<http://ads.anm.co.uk/ADCLICK/CID=fffffffcfffffffcfffffffc/AAMSZ=452x118/SITE=THISISSUTT/AREA=NEWS/SUBAREA=GREAT%20BARR%20NEWS/ARTICLE=388442/acc_random=5582166121/pageid=/RS=>
■ *Pulling his trousers down and exposing him to passing motorists while
working on the M6.*

*■** Force-feeding Mr Mehmood bacon, which it is against his religious
beliefs to eat.*

*■** Dropping him off in Lozells at the time of the Asian/Afro-Carribean
race riots in 2005 and then driving off, telling him the residents would
come and get him.*
*■** Tied Mr Mehmood to railings with duct tape, stripping him and dousing
his clothing in dirty water.*
**
Despite the Crown Court's findings Melaney and Lee Paul McDermott, 31, of
Blue Stone Walk, Rowley Regis, appealed the three-year jail term. Jonathon
Challiner, defending Melaney, told the judges that the incidents were
initially 'horseplay' but conceded it 'developed into a campaign of racial
harassment.

John Evans representing McDermott said: "Mr Mehmood was a quiet man with a
stutter as well as being Asian and this had made the butt of what started
out as practical jokes." Mr Evans said his client thought he got on 'quite
well' with Mr Mehmood and said that the jail term was too long for incidents
that occurred from 'time to time', only eventually escalating.

A third man, Phillip Skett, 39, of College Road, Erdington, did not appeal
his three-year sentence.

*Mr Justice Pitchford, sitting in the criminal appeal court with Lady
Justice Hallett and Judge Nicholas Cooke QC, said the conduct of the pair
had been **'**appalling**'**.*
**
*Refusing the appeal he said Mr Mehmood was: "A man who was vulnerable in
his workplace, by virtue of his personal qualities, his minority race and in
the troubled times in which he was living.*
**
*"We have considered the matter of these men**'**s conduct, its persistence
over a prolonged period and its traumatic effect on their victim. "We
conclude that the sentences were both principled and appropriate."*
**

*Tolerance Born Out of Real Understanding*


*Christelle Sadeghi & Josiane Bechara, Arab News*

*http://arabnews.com/?page=7&section=0&article=98715&d=20&m=7&y=2007*

BRUSSELS/BEIRUT, 20 July 2007 ― *As the world enters a new age of
enlightenment, conflicts plague the earth while large distances between
continents vanish as a result of a newly emerging global community. The
amalgamation of people with different cultural backgrounds, traditions and
values enriches this community, yet it also contributes to the appearance of
ideological deadlocks and collisions. The result is a multitude of vast
cultural clefts separating people today. Hence the search for a process of
peace-making through the promotion of tolerance. *

UNESCO's Declaration of the Principles of Tolerance states that "tolerance
is respect, acceptance and appreciation of the rich diversity of our world's
cultures, our forms of expression and ways of being human. Tolerance is
harmony in difference". The Oxford Dictionary states that tolerance is the
ability to tolerate the beliefs and actions of others and to permit them. It
also describes tolerance as being "the capacity to endure hardship or pain".


However, when the pain of acceptance sometimes exceeds its threshold, can
tolerance still achieve harmony? One could then consider tolerance as
promoting passivity toward injustices that violate our basic human rights.
Without attempting to further understand people who are different from us,
this form of tolerance can actually lead to intolerance. It can shut down
conversations rather than encourage them.

*This kind of tolerance can be a form of avoidance ― it prevents individuals
from asking questions, learning about themselves and others. By defining the
limits of tolerance, one might run the risk of promoting intolerance too.
Instead one should view it as the capacity to question what should and
should not be tolerated through action, not passive acceptance.
Self-criticism should be the basis of this new approach. It is with
self-criticism that one can start to form stronger bonds; delving deeper
into understanding one's self can lead to an understanding of others. *

Xenophobia, a phenomenon that affects the entire world, is the product of a
timorous conscience, namely of individuals who lack sufficient
self-confidence and who do not feel secure in their personal status.
Strangers are thus regarded as a threat. It is precisely when we do not feel
sure of ourselves that we consider others, especially strangers, a danger.

*It is unfortunate to think that attitudes are not changing fast enough.
Many of us had thought that globalization, television, the Internet and
people's increased eagerness to travel would lead to greater tolerance, yet
we are regularly confronted with the opposite. The element of
exclusion/isolation is key. In 2006 a report entitled "Muslims in the
European Union ― Discrimination and Islamophobia" stated that the main
issues in regard to tolerance are, on one hand, a large proportion of
society discriminating against Muslims and, on the other hand, a problem of
self-isolation by Muslims. *

However, the more people live, talk and work together, the more they
recognize the value of the other. Without these kinds of interaction, one
cannot gain recognition of equal value.

It is thus important to see how understanding through self-criticism is a
valuable goal. It involves active dialogue with others, and asking questions
that test our perceptions of others ― such as their religious practices,
traditional attire and belief systems. Instead of quickly developing
preconceived notions, we must define others for ourselves. Genuine
communication is imperative if one is to learn about others on their own
terms. It is also sometimes important to reject a certain state of
conditioning. We retain the right to no longer engage in the negative aspect
of labeling or judgment. Thus, this kind of tolerance can promote the
impetus to refuse corruption, bigotry, and prejudice.

*Instead of passively accepting one's fate by normalizing and tolerating a
corrupt system, one should question, reason and actively criticize. No
longer can we be lenient toward a system bound to self-destruct as a result
of human intolerance. Sometimes a refusal to tolerate the status quo is
needed to galvanize change. It is through active intolerance that one can
improve the basic human welfare of a nation and its citizens. No longer can
one hold onto the constant expectation that tomorrow's policies will solve
today's issues. It is obvious that action toward a better future starts now.
*

Tolerance born out of real understanding becomes a great transformative
activity. It promotes true integration, fusing people from various
backgrounds into a truly global and multicultural community.

*― Josiane Bechara is a researcher at the Issam Fares Institute for Public
Policy and International Affairs at AUB. Christelle Sadeghi is currently a
student at the Universite Libre de Bruxelles, **Belgium**. This article is
distributed by the Common Ground News Service (CGNews).***

Reply via email to