[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/DAEMON-449?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=17634413#comment-17634413 ]
Mark Thomas commented on DAEMON-449: ------------------------------------ I think you are mis-reading the logs. The line [2022-11-14 15:04:19] [debug] ( prunsrv.c:1603) [ 6136] Waiting for worker to finish... shows that the service has started and the service wrapper is now waiting for the service to end before that thread will continue. I suspect what is happening is that server.bat is returning before the service has fully started. Try adding some debug logging to show when server.bat exits. > Prunsrv fails to stop Open Liberty Windows service > -------------------------------------------------- > > Key: DAEMON-449 > URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/DAEMON-449 > Project: Commons Daemon > Issue Type: Bug > Components: prunsrv > Affects Versions: 1.2.2 > Environment: I don't think the Windows version matters, but I am > using: > Microsoft Windows [Version 10.0.19044.2006] > Reporter: Jim Blye > Priority: Major > Attachments: commons-daemon.2022-09-28.log, > commons-daemon.2022-09-28_afterKillingServer.log, server.bat > > > When Prunsrv is used to register Open Liberty > ([https://openliberty.io|https://openliberty.io/]) as a Windows Service, > stopping the service hangs randomly. > *To recreate the problem:* > 1) Download open liberty ~300MB > > [https://public.dhe.ibm.com/ibmdl/export/pub/software/openliberty/runtime/release/22.0.0.10/openliberty-22.0.0.10.zip] > Alternatively, you could use just the liberty kernel ~10MB > > [https://public.dhe.ibm.com/ibmdl/export/pub/software/openliberty/runtime/release/22.0.0.10/openliberty-kernel-22.0.0.10.zip] > 2) md C:\temp\openliberty > unzip openliberty-22.0.0.10.zip into C:\temp\openliberty > 3) cd C:\temp\openliberty\wlp\bin > 4) Run these two commands to make sure the server runs and to initialize > the environment: > server start > server stop > 5) Register liberty as a service (parameter is case sensitive). The > following command is used to invoke prunsrv to register the service using the > default name of defaultServer > server registerWinService > 6) Open the windows "services" app (services.msc). Start and stop the > service until the stop hangs. It usually doesn't take more than a couple of > tries. > > *Details* > The *server.bat* script registers the service like this: > "C:\temp\openliberty\wlp\bin\tools\win\prunsrv.exe" //IS//defaultServer > --Startup=manual --DisplayName="defaultServer" --Description="Open Liberty" > ++DependsOn=Tcpip > --LogPath="C:\temp\openliberty\wlp\usr\servers\defaultServer\logs" > --StdOutput=auto --StdError=auto --StartMode=exe > --StartPath="C:\temp\openliberty\wlp" > --StartImage="C:\temp\openliberty\wlp\bin\server.bat" > ++StartParams=start#defaultServer --StopMode=exe > --StopPath="C:\temp\openliberty\wlp" --StopImage="C:\temp\wlp\bin\server.bat" > ++StopParams=stop#defaultServer --ServiceUser=LocalSystem > After registering the service you can look at its properties. You will see: > Path to executable: > C:\temp\openliberty\wlp\bin\tools\win\prunsrv.exe //RS//defaultServer > When I (and many of our customers) try to stop the service, it hangs. At > that point, the server, named defaultServer is still up and running. I can > send commands to the server. For instance, I can execute a "server dump" > command. This sends the "dump" command to the server, and the server writes > information to a file. I can also stop the server by executing "server > stop". This sends the "stop" command to the server which causes the server > to stop. When the server stops, the hanging Windows service stops as well. > I have attached a *server.bat* which adds --LogLevel Debug to the prunsrv > commands and also *commons-daemon.2022-09-28.log* which demonstrates the > problem. It shows registering, starting, and stopping the service. Finally, > I uploaded {*}commons-daemon.2022-09-28_afterKillingServer.log{*}, which is a > continuation of the other log file which shows the result of issuing the > server stop command to stop the server. > Thanks for looking at this. > Jim Blye -- This message was sent by Atlassian Jira (v8.20.10#820010)