meonkeys commented on PR #6366: URL: https://github.com/apache/fineract/pull/6366#issuecomment-5554119221
@vidakovic thanks for adding your thoughts here! I made changes! Please see 81da32fa7f2fd62670317cdd1c1f06771a5bafcf. > require the _disclosure of AI tool usage_ You're leaning "disclosure is required" and @Aman-Mittal is leaning "optional", so I'll split the difference and make a "recommendation". Regarding "disclosure is required"... why? This can be a side-discussion or whatever, I'm just curious. From https://www.apache.org/legal/generative-tooling.html (as of today) I'm getting "it's a good idea" but not "gen AI use MUST be disclosed". I want to adopt ASF's policies/recommendation around AI use as they're doing their homework on it (and I'm not). > we could extend the checklist there Sure, but--just a side note--I think the checklist is dumb. 98% of the time it is just rubber-stamped. Maybe we require it for new/drive-by contributors, but otherwise it seems like useless red tape. Nevertheless, I added a checkbox in 81da32fa7f2fd62670317cdd1c1f06771a5bafcf. > can we agree on one channel where discussions like these are happening Personally I'm fine with whatever channel fits the use cases of expected response time, privacy, and verbosity, as long as whatever is discussed is logged and searchable forever and copius cross-references are provided. I question your choice to repeat most of your concerns about AI here... This PR is really just about a few salient lines in `CONTRIBUTING.md`. In the future maybe just link instead? > I have a feeling that the moment for a proper (pros and cons) discussion has already passed I disagree. I do think the mailing list back and forth wasn't really helping us move forward. Maybe call a meeting instead? I'll gladly attend. For now we just need _something_ useful in our contributor guidelines. We'll iterate and improve it. -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: [email protected]
