[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/HBASE-12346?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=14184699#comment-14184699
]
Jerry He commented on HBASE-12346:
----------------------------------
HI, [~apurtell]
Thanks for the comment.
I agree that we should not and can not follow Accumulo blindly.
On the contrary, if you think about it, it is probably more ok for Accumulo to
force their scanner applications to setAuthorizations(), since Accumulo has had
it since the beginning. At least no backward compatible issue.
For us, ask users to re-write their read applications to order to use
visibility labels is less desirable and not practical.
While doing enablement and advocacy work for this feature, the feedbacks I got
include 'confusion'.
Stacking multiple label generators will do the trick. But it is probably more
suitable for advanced users and will complicate things.
I think a reasonable and practical out-of-box experience is more important.
> Scan's default auths behavior under Visibility labels
> -----------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: HBASE-12346
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/HBASE-12346
> Project: HBase
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: API, security
> Affects Versions: 0.98.7, 0.99.1
> Reporter: Jerry He
> Attachments: HBASE-12346-master.patch
>
>
> In Visibility Labels security, a set of labels (auths) are administered and
> associated with a user.
> A user can normally only see cell data during scan that are part of the
> user's label set (auths).
> Scan uses setAuthorizations to indicates its wants to use the auths to access
> the cells.
> Similarly in the shell:
> {code}
> scan 'table1', AUTHORIZATIONS => ['private']
> {code}
> But it is a surprise to find that setAuthorizations seems to be 'mandatory'
> in the default visibility label security setting. Every scan needs to
> setAuthorizations before the scan can get any cells even the cells are under
> the labels the request user is part of.
> The following steps will illustrate the issue:
> Run as superuser.
> {code}
> 1. create a visibility label called 'private'
> 2. create 'table1'
> 3. put into 'table1' data and label the data as 'private'
> 4. set_auths 'user1', 'private'
> 5. grant 'user1', 'RW', 'table1'
> {code}
> Run as 'user1':
> {code}
> 1. scan 'table1'
> This show no cells.
> 2. scan 'table1', scan 'table1', AUTHORIZATIONS => ['private']
> This will show all the data.
> {code}
> I am not sure if this is expected by design or a bug.
> But a more reasonable, more client application backward compatible, and less
> surprising default behavior should probably look like this:
> A scan's default auths, if its Authorizations attributes is not set
> explicitly, should be all the auths the request user is administered and
> allowed on the server.
> If scan.setAuthorizations is used, then the server further filter the auths
> during scan: use the input auths minus what is not in user's label set on the
> server.
--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.3.4#6332)
