Mark Payne created NIP-28:
-----------------------------

             Summary: Allow Connectors to have a 'Break Glass in Case of 
Emergency' Troubleshooting mode
                 Key: NIP-28
                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/NIP-28
             Project: NiFi Improvement Proposal
          Issue Type: Improvement
            Reporter: Mark Payne


h2. Motivation

The design for Connectors (https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/NIP-11) was 
that these are self-contained end-to-end abstractions. The Connector manages 
the flow by itself and while the user should be able to view the flow, they 
should not be able to modify it in any way, except configuring the Connector.

While this makes sense, it also takes away the ability to troubleshoot in the 
way that we are used to with NiFi.

 
h2. Proposed Solution

The proposal is to allow for a 'Troubleshooting' mode for Connectors. In this 
mode, the Connector's flow will be modifiable. The user can go in and 
add/delete/update components. But they will not be able to Start, Stop, or 
update the configuration of the Connector itself.

This allows for quickly addressing any issues that come up while the Connector 
is running. But we cannot have code that expects to manage the flow while at 
the same time allowing users to manipulate the flow. So this provides the 
ability to effectively switch between the flow being managed by the Connector 
and the flow being managed by the user.

Once the user has resolved the issue, they can exit the Troubleshooting mode. 
At that point, the Connector will resume the responsibility of managing the 
flow, and the user will no longer be able to manipulate it. This means that the 
Connector will immediately revert any changes made to the flow so that the flow 
matches what the Connector expects.

If the desire were to have these flow changes become permanent, a new version 
of the Connector would need to be created and deployed.

 



--
This message was sent by Atlassian Jira
(v8.20.10#820010)

Reply via email to