[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/TS-2983?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=14088778#comment-14088778
]
James Peach commented on TS-2983:
---------------------------------
I think it's a matter of symmetry. If you can probe for a protocol, then the
underlying transport should not matter. I agree that for the specific cases of
HTTP/2 and SPDY there's no point in doing it, but we should avoid the special
case just on principle. If someone were to argue that we should not do protocol
probing at all, I would not mind.
> request headers, http object corrupted in 5.0.x
> -----------------------------------------------
>
> Key: TS-2983
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/TS-2983
> Project: Traffic Server
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: Core
> Affects Versions: 5.1.0
> Reporter: Sudheer Vinukonda
> Priority: Blocker
> Fix For: 5.1.0
>
> Attachments: TS-2983.diff
>
>
> We have run into a http header/field corruption issue on our proxy
> infrastructure production hosts when we enabled 5.0.x. The issue results in
> host header/method and other field corruption.
> For example, this is what we see in our squid access logs:
> {code}
> 1406999819.698 0 69.109.120.92 ERR_CONNECT_FAIL 404 0 nas=0&disclaimer=2;
> https://AMCV_att1=MCAID%7C29B9EEB305013EE7-4000010900024C7D;%20ypcdb=27a2458b603f6370d295cf4130825e34/
> - NONE/- -
> https://AMCV_att1=MCAID%7C29B9EEB305013EE7-4000010900024C7D;%20ypcdb=27a2458b603f6370d295cf4130825e34/
> f1 f2 f3 f4
> 1406999819.698 4 69.109.120.92 ERR_CONNECT_FAIL 404 1825 nas=0&disclaimer=2;
> https://AMCV_att1=MCAID%7C29B9EEB305013EE7-4000010900024C7D;%20ypcdb=27a2458b603f6370d295cf4130825e34/
> - NONE/- text/html
> https://AMCV_att1=MCAID%7C29B9EEB305013EE7-4000010900024C7D;%20ypcdb=27a2458b603f6370d295cf4130825e34/
> f1 f2 f3 f4
> 1406999834.692 0 69.109.120.92 ERR_CONNECT_FAIL 404 0 nas=0&disclaimer=2;
> https://AMCV_att1=MCAID%7C29B9EEB305013EE7-4000010900024C7D;%20ypcdb=27a2458b603f6370d295cf4130825e34/
> - NONE/- -
> https://AMCV_att1=MCAID%7C29B9EEB305013EE7-4000010900024C7D;%20ypcdb=27a2458b603f6370d295cf4130825e34/
> f1 f2 f3 f4
> 1406999834.692 4 69.109.120.92 ERR_CONNECT_FAIL 404 1825 nas=0&disclaimer=2;
> https://AMCV_att1=MCAID%7C29B9EEB305013EE7-4000010900024C7D;%20ypcdb=27a2458b603f6370d295cf4130825e34/
> - NONE/- text/html
> https://AMCV_att1=MCAID%7C29B9EEB305013EE7-4000010900024C7D;%20ypcdb=27a2458b603f6370d295cf4130825e34/
> f1 f2 f3 f4
> 1406999842.475 0 75.15.121.107 ERR_CONNECT_FAIL 404 0
> 435OjuZl6UyTXTs38eKhUO5C7Vs4E7FRajuU3BHWqLQxY4GMkRCgkGTvCOJPimsE1aB2W5hj_Qh70_dy7aJoas2DbmaCbIJ6UgkbkUINLhJbjDnfx3pKtVSlFca1VB6zCYSEkCswU_dULV6p2FtUs5aVRCZl2kVCmvy9esXiSqqXN1oYxAPe6l5bHM9yLOVNIRmaFTRcSHLm3e3lIp5Bx3Wismutrnp8nddMtqoz8xhLLUTVrid1YGmu0kPQxEhn8kJtm_8E2Kw48yhiy.slyxhwZPtI3rHRz42B4MrcvGBnZiglC0f0FCHYBcHVZ4B0eqCXX3hNNH_.xj9xqHfRJzRaL0c6DwuiVFiyd4UcID3uhp6e1Y5EAh0lN4_gJPFCxnyrqnzw1T31w.TuhS9Rz98ZlNHVvsN6kLnKq5JmxocK7X4rmzOKNmmY9e85vEhQS7c4fN69JtzyvdbNUWY_4x6iYU4rvIu30miN.klS8iqD_W8g_6Xl.iclrYt_AKdUJ59qhj9V54JDebWuybPyZHLB.h2ZOKzbIyO9qUiZUY.5eqiHeupe_3ZieCViVpkCVKoiEunj1bPRd9tuxcNel.GmAtDPjRCwUH3WVCz3zq34rY6VBG2EeNQyLNNTT1GEHiXQ7k_ykZeQ6qCZGSZPpqz0S5we2qshU69hR1grm1Pyxli2Pv8uZ3YqL2FUQow0zZdtejnsxosoFqfge_mWnnHq9gmXkfc0RdgUevblIr50wC6stwTwjbW2MqOo2zyrRkp99Uprxah2olhrbw7Zc2yFDuCG5A4.R_3crXB8fp6iwmdlGnDfRa1oaHXn3Kves9YbZLtp1sUmQFmPoKr7Fu0qgxSHPDagEqhQXFnV3YpZ0LHdvir7MWFKg2bzh3OlrDeaGe0KK.xl8Y2OkckdNvQ.ho6F9AElt5GBACSl2kaVKChw8xa5xUOT0x8FYzFfgGk6syEESBPxvloY7OpdDGh3LUovu00N7z2z8lhC.LvYwmEdMeuS.5qq5yAE4jGWSlXXBBgUBXqyTFJ3IZUbm1gPvOCbEVELrbEvc7n0Gw_D_TjHcbNHN7rzXqad;
>
> https://YLS=v=1&p=1&n=0;%20ucs=bnas=1&bnid=SGZJL05rb2dzRzN3dTd5UDJWdFdqUT09;%20_br_uid_2=uid%3D7216053621378%3A_uid%3D8562842167448%3Av%3D10.6.1%3Ats%3D1324745461005%3Ahc%3D11/
> - NONE/- -
> https://YLS=v=1&p=1&n=0;%20ucs=bnas=1&bnid=SGZJL05rb2dzRzN3dTd5UDJWdFdqUT09;%20_br_uid_2=uid%3D7216053621378%3A_uid%3D8562842167448%3Av%3D10.6.1%3Ats%3D1324745461005%3Ahc%3D11/
> f1 f2 f3 f4
> 1406999842.475 0 75.15.121.107 ERR_CONNECT_FAIL 404 1897
> 435OjuZl6UyTXTs38eKhUO5C7Vs4E7FRajuU3BHWqLQxY4GMkRCgkGTvCOJPimsE1aB2W5hj_Qh70_dy7aJoas2DbmaCbIJ6UgkbkUINLhJbjDnfx3pKtVSlFca1VB6zCYSEkCswU_dULV6p2FtUs5aVRCZl2kVCmvy9esXiSqqXN1oYxAPe6l5bHM9yLOVNIRmaFTRcSHLm3e3lIp5Bx3Wismutrnp8nddMtqoz8xhLLUTVrid1YGmu0kPQxEhn8kJtm_8E2Kw48yhiy.slyxhwZPtI3rHRz42B4MrcvGBnZiglC0f0FCHYBcHVZ4B0eqCXX3hNNH_.xj9xqHfRJzRaL0c6DwuiVFiyd4UcID3uhp6e1Y5EAh0lN4_gJPFCxnyrqnzw1T31w.TuhS9Rz98ZlNHVvsN6kLnKq5JmxocK7X4rmzOKNmmY9e85vEhQS7c4fN69JtzyvdbNUWY_4x6iYU4rvIu30miN.klS8iqD_W8g_6Xl.iclrYt_AKdUJ59qhj9V54JDebWuybPyZHLB.h2ZOKzbIyO9qUiZUY.5eqiHeupe_3ZieCViVpkCVKoiEunj1bPRd9tuxcNel.GmAtDPjRCwUH3WVCz3zq34rY6VBG2EeNQyLNNTT1GEHiXQ7k_ykZeQ6qCZGSZPpqz0S5we2qshU69hR1grm1Pyxli2Pv8uZ3YqL2FUQow0zZdtejnsxosoFqfge_mWnnHq9gmXkfc0RdgUevblIr50wC6stwTwjbW2MqOo2zyrRkp99Uprxah2olhrbw7Zc2yFDuCG5A4.R_3crXB8fp6iwmdlGnDfRa1oaHXn3Kves9YbZLtp1sUmQFmPoKr7Fu0qgxSHPDagEqhQXFnV3YpZ0LHdvir7MWFKg2bzh3OlrDeaGe0KK.xl8Y2OkckdNvQ.ho6F9AElt5GBACSl2kaVKChw8xa5xUOT0x8FYzFfgGk6syEESBPxvloY7OpdDGh3LUovu00N7z2z8lhC.LvYwmEdMeuS.5qq5yAE4jGWSlXXBBgUBXqyTFJ3IZUbm1gPvOCbEVELrbEvc7n0Gw_D_TjHcbNHN7rzXqad;
>
> https://YLS=v=1&p=1&n=0;%20ucs=bnas=1&bnid=SGZJL05rb2dzRzN3dTd5UDJWdFdqUT09;%20_br_uid_2=uid%3D7216053621378%3A_uid%3D8562842167448%3Av%3D10.6.1%3Ats%3D1324745461005%3Ahc%3D11/
> - NONE/- text/html
> https://YLS=v=1&p=1&n=0;%20ucs=bnas=1&bnid=SGZJL05rb2dzRzN3dTd5UDJWdFdqUT09;%20_br_uid_2=uid%3D7216053621378%3A_uid%3D8562842167448%3Av%3D10.6.1%3Ats%3D1324745461005%3Ahc%3D11/
> f1 f2 f3 f4
> 1406999842.735 0 75.15.121.107 ERR_CONNECT_FAIL 404 0
> 435OjuZl6UyTXTs38eKhUO5C7Vs4E7FRajuU3BHWqLQxY4GMkRCgkGTvCOJPimsE1aB2W5hj_Qh70_dy7aJoas2DbmaCbIJ6UgkbkUINLhJbjDnfx3pKtVSlFca1VB6zCYSEkCswU_dULV6p2FtUs5aVRCZl2kVCmvy9esXiSqqXN1oYxAPe6l5bHM9yLOVNIRmaFTRcSHLm3e3lIp5Bx3Wismutrnp8nddMtqoz8xhLLUTVrid1YGmu0kPQxEhn8kJtm_8E2Kw48yhiy.slyxhwZPtI3rHRz42B4MrcvGBnZiglC0f0FCHYBcHVZ4B0eqCXX3hNNH_.xj9xqHfRJzRaL0c6DwuiVFiyd4UcID3uhp6e1Y5EAh0lN4_gJPFCxnyrqnzw1T31w.TuhS9Rz98ZlNHVvsN6kLnKq5JmxocK7X4rmzOKNmmY9e85vEhQS7c4fN69JtzyvdbNUWY_4x6iYU4rvIu30miN.klS8iqD_W8g_6Xl.iclrYt_AKdUJ59qhj9V54JDebWuybPyZHLB.h2ZOKzbIyO9qUiZUY.5eqiHeupe_3ZieCViVpkCVKoiEunj1bPRd9tuxcNel.GmAtDPjRCwUH3WVCz3zq34rY6VBG2EeNQyLNNTT1GEHiXQ7k_ykZeQ6qCZGSZPpqz0S5we2qshU69hR1grm1Pyxli2Pv8uZ3YqL2FUQow0zZdtejnsxosoFqfge_mWnnHq9gmXkfc0RdgUevblIr50wC6stwTwjbW2MqOo2zyrRkp99Uprxah2olhrbw7Zc2yFDuCG5A4.R_3crXB8fp6iwmdlGnDfRa1oaHXn3Kves9YbZLtp1sUmQFmPoKr7Fu0qgxSHPDagEqhQXFnV3YpZ0LHdvir7MWFKg2bzh3OlrDeaGe0KK.xl8Y2OkckdNvQ.ho6F9AElt5GBACSl2kaVKChw8xa5xUOT0x8FYzFfgGk6syEESBPxvloY7OpdDGh3LUovu00N7z2z8lhC.LvYwmEdMeuS.5qq5yAE4jGWSlXXBBgUBXqyTFJ3IZUbm1gPvOCbEVELrbEvc7n0Gw_D_TjHcbNHN7rzXqad;
>
> https://YLS=v=1&p=1&n=0;%20ucs=bnas=1&bnid=SGZJL05rb2dzRzN3dTd5UDJWdFdqUT09;%20_br_uid_2=uid%3D7216053621378%3A_uid%3D8562842167448%3Av%3D10.6.1%3Ats%3D1324745461005%3Ahc%3D11/
> - NONE/- -
> https://YLS=v=1&p=1&n=0;%20ucs=bnas=1&bnid=SGZJL05rb2dzRzN3dTd5UDJWdFdqUT09;%20_br_uid_2=uid%3D7216053621378%3A_uid%3D8562842167448%3Av%3D10.6.1%3Ats%3D1324745461005%3Ahc%3D11/
> f1 f2 f3 f4
> 1406999842.735 0 75.15.121.107 ERR_CONNECT_FAIL 404 1897
> 435OjuZl6UyTXTs38eKhUO5C7Vs4E7FRajuU3BHWqLQxY4GMkRCgkGTvCOJPimsE1aB2W5hj_Qh70_dy7aJoas2DbmaCbIJ6UgkbkUINLhJbjDnfx3pKtVSlFca1VB6zCYSEkCswU_dULV6p2FtUs5aVRCZl2kVCmvy9esXiSqqXN1oYxAPe6l5bHM9yLOVNIRmaFTRcSHLm3e3lIp5Bx3Wismutrnp8nddMtqoz8xhLLUTVrid1YGmu0kPQxEhn8kJtm_8E2Kw48yhiy.slyxhwZPtI3rHRz42B4MrcvGBnZiglC0f0FCHYBcHVZ4B0eqCXX3hNNH_.xj9xqHfRJzRaL0c6DwuiVFiyd4UcID3uhp6e1Y5EAh0lN4_gJPFCxnyrqnzw1T31w.TuhS9Rz98ZlNHVvsN6kLnKq5JmxocK7X4rmzOKNmmY9e85vEhQS7c4fN69JtzyvdbNUWY_4x6iYU4rvIu30miN.klS8iqD_W8g_6Xl.iclrYt_AKdUJ59qhj9V54JDebWuybPyZHLB.h2ZOKzbIyO9qUiZUY.5eqiHeupe_3ZieCViVpkCVKoiEunj1bPRd9tuxcNel.GmAtDPjRCwUH3WVCz3zq34rY6VBG2EeNQyLNNTT1GEHiXQ7k_ykZeQ6qCZGSZPpqz0S5we2qshU69hR1grm1Pyxli2Pv8uZ3YqL2FUQow0zZdtejnsxosoFqfge_mWnnHq9gmXkfc0RdgUevblIr50wC6stwTwjbW2MqOo2zyrRkp99Uprxah2olhrbw7Zc2yFDuCG5A4.R_3crXB8fp6iwmdlGnDfRa1oaHXn3Kves9YbZLtp1sUmQFmPoKr7Fu0qgxSHPDagEqhQXFnV3YpZ0LHdvir7MWFKg2bzh3OlrDeaGe0KK.xl8Y2OkckdNvQ.ho6F9AElt5GBACSl2kaVKChw8xa5xUOT0x8FYzFfgGk6syEESBPxvloY7OpdDGh3LUovu00N7z2z8lhC.LvYwmEdMeuS.5qq5yAE4jGWSlXXBBgUBXqyTFJ3IZUbm1gPvOCbEVELrbEvc7n0Gw_D_TjHcbNHN7rzXqad;
>
> https://YLS=v=1&p=1&n=0;%20ucs=bnas=1&bnid=SGZJL05rb2dzRzN3dTd5UDJWdFdqUT09;%20_br_uid_2=uid%3D7216053621378%3A_uid%3D8562842167448%3Av%3D10.6.1%3Ats%3D1324745461005%3Ahc%3D11/
> - NONE/- text/html
> https://YLS=v=1&p=1&n=0;%20ucs=bnas=1&bnid=SGZJL05rb2dzRzN3dTd5UDJWdFdqUT09;%20_br_uid_2=uid%3D7216053621378%3A_uid%3D8562842167448%3Av%3D10.6.1%3Ats%3D1324745461005%3Ahc%3D11/
> f1 f2 f3 f4
> {code}
> After a lot of debugging, figured that the request was getting corrupted even
> before remap and in fact, is being parsed incorrectly at the read request
> state. Further analysis lead me to the commit TS-2197 (commit
> 30fcc2b2e698831d1a9e4db1474d8cfc202818a3 in Oct'13), which has altered the
> way the request is read slightly. Reverting the commit seems to have fixed
> the issue.
--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.2#6252)
