Re: too much warnings when building ivy

[Xavier Hanin]

On 6/7/07, Gilles Scokart <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

I added the warning because it is rather strange to sort modules with
non matching revision in the buildlist task.  When you invoke a
buillist to order modules that has non matching revision, the sort
algorithm will consider it is two different modules, and will not
order them correctly.  In such a case, warning the user seemed to be
important.

But you are right, during a retrieve the warning should not be there.

So maybe we should use the DefaultNonMatchingVersionReporter only for the
build list task, and use an ignore implementation for other cases?

Xavier

Gilles

2007/6/7, Xavier Hanin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:
> On 6/7/07, Maarten Coene <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> >
> > Hi,
> >
> > when I build Ivy, I get a lot of warnings after resolving the
dependencies
> > (see below).
> > Any idea what they mean and how we can solve (or ignore) them?
>
>
> Indeed, I noticed that too. It seems to be related to the new sort
> implementation (see
> CollectionOfModulesToSort#getModuleDescriptorDependency).
>
> The problem I see here is that warnings are output by default while this
is
> a very usual case to find non matching revisions. Gilles, could you
explain
> what was your intention with these warnings?
>
> Xavier
>
> Maarten
> >
> >
> > [ivy:retrieve] :: problems summary ::
> > [ivy:retrieve] :::: WARNINGS
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-httpclient
|
> > commons-
> > httpclient ] depends on [ junit | junit | 3.8.1 ], doesn't match
module: [
> > junit
> > | junit | 3.8.2 ] status=integration publication=Mon May 14 23:34:53
CEST
> > 2007
> > configurations={default=default, master=master, compile=compile,
> > provided=provid
> > ed, runtime=runtime, test=test, system=system} artifacts={master=[[
junit
> > | juni
> > t | 3.8.2 ]/junit.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-httpclient
|
> > commons-
> > httpclient ] depends on [ commons-logging | commons-logging | 1.0.3 ],
> > doesn't m
> > atch module: [ commons-logging | commons-logging | 1.0.4 ]
> > status=integration pu
> > blication=Tue Nov 08 23:16:41 CET 2005
configurations={default=default,
> > master=m
> > aster, compile=compile, provided=provided, runtime=runtime, test=test,
> > system=sy
> > stem, optional=optional} artifacts={master=[[ commons-logging |
> > commons-logging
> > | 1.0.4 ]/commons-logging.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[dependency: [ log4j
|
> > log4j |
> > 1.2.6 ] {optional=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}, dependency: [
> > logkit |
> > logkit | 1.0.1 ] {optional=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]},
> > dependency: [ j
> > unit | junit | 3.7 ] {test=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]},
> > dependency: [ a
> > valon-framework | avalon-framework | 4.1.3 ] {optional=[compile(*),
> > runtime(*),
> > master(*)]}]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-logging |
> > commons-log
> > ging ] depends on [ junit | junit | 3.7 ], doesn't match module: [
junit |
> > junit
> > | 3.8.2 ] status=integration publication=Mon May 14 23:34:53 CEST 2007
> > configur
> > ations={default=default, master=master, compile=compile,
> > provided=provided, runt
> > ime=runtime, test=test, system=system} artifacts={master=[[ junit |
junit
> > | 3.8.
> > 2 ]/junit.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-logging |
> > commons-log
> > ging ] depends on [ junit | junit | 3.7 ], doesn't match module: [
junit |
> > junit
> > | 3.8.1 ] status=integration publication=Mon May 14 23:34:18 CEST 2007
> > configur
> > ations={default=default, master=master, compile=compile,
> > provided=provided, runt
> > ime=runtime, test=test, system=system} artifacts={master=[[ junit |
junit
> > | 3.8.
> > 1 ]/junit.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-cli |
> > commons-cli ] d
> > epends on [ commons-logging | commons-logging | 1.0 ], doesn't match
> > module: [ c
> > ommons-logging | commons-logging | 1.0.4 ] status=integration
> > publication=Tue No
> > v 08 23:16:41 CET 2005 configurations={default=default, master=master,
> > compile=c
> > ompile, provided=provided, runtime=runtime, test=test, system=system,
> > optional=o
> > ptional} artifacts={master=[[ commons-logging | commons-logging |
1.0.4]/common
> > s-logging.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[dependency: [ log4j | log4j | 1.2.6]
> > {option
> > al=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}, dependency: [ logkit | logkit
|
> > 1.0.1 ]
> > {optional=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}, dependency: [ junit |
> > junit | 3
> > .7 ] {test=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}, dependency: [
> > avalon-framework
> > | avalon-framework | 4.1.3 ] {optional=[compile(*), runtime(*),
> > master(*)]}]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-cli |
> > commons-cli ] d
> > epends on [ commons-logging | commons-logging | 1.0 ], doesn't match
> > module: [ c
> > ommons-logging | commons-logging | 1.0.3 ] status=integration
> > publication=Thu No
> > v 17 14:22:22 CET 2005 configurations={default=default, master=master,
> > compile=c
> > ompile, provided=provided, runtime=runtime, test=test, system=system,
> > optional=o
> > ptional} artifacts={master=[[ commons-logging | commons-logging |
1.0.3]/common
> > s-logging.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[dependency: [ log4j | log4j | 1.2.6]
> > {option
> > al=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}, dependency: [ logkit | logkit
|
> > 1.0.1 ]
> > {optional=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}, dependency: [ junit |
> > junit | 3
> > .7 ] {test=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-lang |
> > commons-lang ]
> > depends on [ junit | junit | 3.7 ], doesn't match module: [ junit |
junit
> > | 3.8
> > .2 ] status=integration publication=Mon May 14 23:34:53 CEST 2007
> > configurations
> > ={default=default, master=master, compile=compile, provided=provided,
> > runtime=ru
> > ntime, test=test, system=system} artifacts={master=[[ junit | junit |
> > 3.8.2 ]/ju
> > nit.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-lang |
> > commons-lang ]
> > depends on [ junit | junit | 3.7 ], doesn't match module: [ junit |
junit
> > | 3.8
> > .1 ] status=integration publication=Mon May 14 23:34:18 CEST 2007
> > configurations
> > ={default=default, master=master, compile=compile, provided=provided,
> > runtime=ru
> > ntime, test=test, system=system} artifacts={master=[[ junit | junit |
> > 3.8.1 ]/ju
> > nit.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-cli |
> > commons-cli ] d
> > epends on [ junit | junit | 3.7 ], doesn't match module: [ junit |
junit |
> > 3.8.2
> > ] status=integration publication=Mon May 14 23:34:53 CEST 2007
> > configurations={
> > default=default, master=master, compile=compile, provided=provided,
> > runtime=runt
> > ime, test=test, system=system} artifacts={master=[[ junit | junit |
3.8.2]/juni
> > t.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-cli |
> > commons-cli ] d
> > epends on [ junit | junit | 3.7 ], doesn't match module: [ junit |
junit |
> > 3.8.1
> > ] status=integration publication=Mon May 14 23:34:18 CEST 2007
> > configurations={
> > default=default, master=master, compile=compile, provided=provided,
> > runtime=runt
> > ime, test=test, system=system} artifacts={master=[[ junit | junit |
3.8.1]/juni
> > t.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-logging |
> > commons-log
> > ging ] depends on [ junit | junit | 3.7 ], doesn't match module: [
junit |
> > junit
> > | 3.8.2 ] status=integration publication=Mon May 14 23:34:53 CEST 2007
> > configur
> > ations={default=default, master=master, compile=compile,
> > provided=provided, runt
> > ime=runtime, test=test, system=system} artifacts={master=[[ junit |
junit
> > | 3.8.
> > 2 ]/junit.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-logging |
> > commons-log
> > ging ] depends on [ junit | junit | 3.7 ], doesn't match module: [
junit |
> > junit
> > | 3.8.1 ] status=integration publication=Mon May 14 23:34:18 CEST 2007
> > configur
> > ations={default=default, master=master, compile=compile,
> > provided=provided, runt
> > ime=runtime, test=test, system=system} artifacts={master=[[ junit |
junit
> > | 3.8.
> > 1 ]/junit.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-vfs |
> > commons-vfs ] d
> > epends on [ commons-httpclient | commons-httpclient | 2.0 ], doesn't
match
> > modul
> > e: [ commons-httpclient | commons-httpclient | 3.0 ]
status=integration
> > publicat
> > ion=Tue Dec 20 06:34:26 CET 2005 configurations={default=default,
> > master=master,
> > compile=compile, provided=provided, runtime=runtime, test=test,
> > system=system}
> > artifacts={master=[[ commons-httpclient | commons-httpclient | 3.0
]/commons-htt
> > pclient.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[dependency: [ junit | junit | 3.8.1 ]
> > {compile=
> > [compile(*), master(*)], runtime=[runtime(*)]}, dependency: [
> > commons-logging |
> > commons-logging | 1.0.3 ] {compile=[compile(*), master(*)],
> > runtime=[runtime(*)]
> > }, dependency: [ commons-codec | commons-codec | 1.2 ]
> > {compile=[compile(*), mas
> > ter(*)], runtime=[runtime(*)]}]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-httpclient
|
> > commons-
> > httpclient ] depends on [ commons-logging | commons-logging | 1.0.3 ],
> > doesn't m
> > atch module: [ commons-logging | commons-logging | 1.0.4 ]
> > status=integration pu
> > blication=Tue Nov 08 23:16:41 CET 2005
configurations={default=default,
> > master=m
> > aster, compile=compile, provided=provided, runtime=runtime, test=test,
> > system=sy
> > stem, optional=optional} artifacts={master=[[ commons-logging |
> > commons-logging
> > | 1.0.4 ]/commons-logging.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[dependency: [ log4j
|
> > log4j |
> > 1.2.6 ] {optional=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}, dependency: [
> > logkit |
> > logkit | 1.0.1 ] {optional=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]},
> > dependency: [ j
> > unit | junit | 3.7 ] {test=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]},
> > dependency: [ a
> > valon-framework | avalon-framework | 4.1.3 ] {optional=[compile(*),
> > runtime(*),
> > master(*)]}]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-logging |
> > commons-log
> > ging ] depends on [ junit | junit | 3.7 ], doesn't match module: [
junit |
> > junit
> > | 3.8.1 ] status=integration publication=Mon May 14 23:34:18 CEST 2007
> > configur
> > ations={default=default, master=master, compile=compile,
> > provided=provided, runt
> > ime=runtime, test=test, system=system} artifacts={master=[[ junit |
junit
> > | 3.8.
> > 1 ]/junit.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-cli |
> > commons-cli ] d
> > epends on [ commons-logging | commons-logging | 1.0 ], doesn't match
> > module: [ c
> > ommons-logging | commons-logging | 1.0.4 ] status=integration
> > publication=Tue No
> > v 08 23:16:41 CET 2005 configurations={default=default, master=master,
> > compile=c
> > ompile, provided=provided, runtime=runtime, test=test, system=system,
> > optional=o
> > ptional} artifacts={master=[[ commons-logging | commons-logging |
1.0.4]/common
> > s-logging.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[dependency: [ log4j | log4j | 1.2.6]
> > {option
> > al=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}, dependency: [ logkit | logkit
|
> > 1.0.1 ]
> > {optional=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}, dependency: [ junit |
> > junit | 3
> > .7 ] {test=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}, dependency: [
> > avalon-framework
> > | avalon-framework | 4.1.3 ] {optional=[compile(*), runtime(*),
> > master(*)]}]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-cli |
> > commons-cli ] d
> > epends on [ commons-logging | commons-logging | 1.0 ], doesn't match
> > module: [ c
> > ommons-logging | commons-logging | 1.0.3 ] status=integration
> > publication=Thu No
> > v 17 14:22:22 CET 2005 configurations={default=default, master=master,
> > compile=c
> > ompile, provided=provided, runtime=runtime, test=test, system=system,
> > optional=o
> > ptional} artifacts={master=[[ commons-logging | commons-logging |
1.0.3]/common
> > s-logging.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[dependency: [ log4j | log4j | 1.2.6]
> > {option
> > al=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}, dependency: [ logkit | logkit
|
> > 1.0.1 ]
> > {optional=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}, dependency: [ junit |
> > junit | 3
> > .7 ] {test=[compile(*), runtime(*), master(*)]}]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-lang |
> > commons-lang ]
> > depends on [ junit | junit | 3.7 ], doesn't match module: [ junit |
junit
> > | 3.8
> > .1 ] status=integration publication=Mon May 14 23:34:18 CEST 2007
> > configurations
> > ={default=default, master=master, compile=compile, provided=provided,
> > runtime=ru
> > ntime, test=test, system=system} artifacts={master=[[ junit | junit |
> > 3.8.1 ]/ju
> > nit.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-cli |
> > commons-cli ] d
> > epends on [ junit | junit | 3.7 ], doesn't match module: [ junit |
junit |
> > 3.8.1
> > ] status=integration publication=Mon May 14 23:34:18 CEST 2007
> > configurations={
> > default=default, master=master, compile=compile, provided=provided,
> > runtime=runt
> > ime, test=test, system=system} artifacts={master=[[ junit | junit |
3.8.1]/juni
> > t.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-logging |
> > commons-log
> > ging ] depends on [ junit | junit | 3.7 ], doesn't match module: [
junit |
> > junit
> > | 3.8.1 ] status=integration publication=Mon May 14 23:34:18 CEST 2007
> > configur
> > ations={default=default, master=master, compile=compile,
> > provided=provided, runt
> > ime=runtime, test=test, system=system} artifacts={master=[[ junit |
junit
> > | 3.8.
> > 1 ]/junit.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[]
> > [ivy:retrieve]  Non matching revision detected.  [ commons-vfs |
> > commons-vfs ] d
> > epends on [ commons-httpclient | commons-httpclient | 2.0 ], doesn't
match
> > modul
> > e: [ commons-httpclient | commons-httpclient | 3.0 ]
status=integration
> > publicat
> > ion=Tue Dec 20 06:34:26 CET 2005 configurations={default=default,
> > master=master,
> > compile=compile, provided=provided, runtime=runtime, test=test,
> > system=system}
> > artifacts={master=[[ commons-httpclient | commons-httpclient | 3.0
]/commons-htt
> > pclient.jar[jar]]} dependencies=[dependency: [ junit | junit | 3.8.1 ]
> > {compile=
> > [compile(*), master(*)], runtime=[runtime(*)]}, dependency: [
> > commons-logging |
> > commons-logging | 1.0.3 ] {compile=[compile(*), master(*)],
> > runtime=[runtime(*)]
> > }, dependency: [ commons-codec | commons-codec | 1.2 ]
> > {compile=[compile(*), mas
> > ter(*)], runtime=[runtime(*)]}]
> > [ivy:retrieve]
> > [ivy:retrieve] :: USE VERBOSE OR DEBUG MESSAGE LEVEL FOR MORE DETAILS
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
____________________________________________________________________________________
> > Luggage? GPS? Comic books?
> > Check out fitting gifts for grads at Yahoo! Search
> > http://search.yahoo.com/search?fr=oni_on_mail&p=graduation+gifts&cs=bz
> >
>
>
>
> --
> Xavier Hanin - Independent Java Consultant
> Manage your dependencies with Ivy!
> http://incubator.apache.org/ivy/
>


--
Gilles SCOKART

--
Xavier Hanin - Independent Java Consultant
Manage your dependencies with Ivy!
http://incubator.apache.org/ivy/