I have the following probably pretty common use case. It is an issue related to maven pom's.

Let's say I declare a dependency on the groovy-all module. The groovy- all pom declares 9 optional dependencies. I need one of of the optional dependencies for my usage scenario of groovy-all. If you are a Maven2 users there is no good way of dealing with this situation. What you have to do, is to declare the optional dependency you want as a first level dependency in your pom. How can I deal with this in Ivy? The module descriptor created out of the pom, has two configurations I'm interested in. This is default (Maven's compile and runtime scope) and optional (all dependencies declared optional in the pom). Now I can do the following:

<dependency org="org.codehaus.groovy" name="groovy-all" rev="1.5.1" conf="compile->default,optional"/>

This add all 9 optional dependencies to the compile configuration. But I want only one. As I understand Ivy, I can only apply exclude and include filtering to the master configuration. In this case that would mean I have to add 8 exclude statements to exclude the unwanted optional dependencies. Alternatively I could declare include statements for all the required dependencies. Both is pretty impractical. I would like to declare filters on the dependency configuration, to say something like: include MODULE_X of OPTIONAL

My work around right now is to do it the same way as I did with Maven. Declaring the optional dependency as a first level dependency.

Is there a better solution to this problem or are there plans to provide one? I'm happy to file a Jira issue :)

- Hans




Reply via email to