On Apr 19, 2005, at 10:06 PM, Mario Alejandro M. wrote:

LIke maybe know, I'm porting Lucene to Delphi.

Taking in account that this is in progress and not a functional release as
be made (however, today I archive ALPHA 2 when all indexing stuff is
working) what can help me in not wast time on it?

There is a concerted effort to develop a SWIG Lucene and there is also a CLucene and an active Lucene4C project. I was crazy enough to contemplate a native Ruby port once upon a time, and developed some low-level I/O code and then realized what a maintenance hassle it'd be to keep up with the always evolving Java Lucene.


The PyLucene crew (credit where its due, Andi Vajda!) did something quite amazing... using GCJ and SWIG to interface Java Lucene with Python. This, in my opinion, is the way to future "ports" to any language. Let Java Lucene be the base and all other ports derive from it. I'm not sure why motivates Garrett with Lucene4C - and I certainly do not want to discourage anyone from tackling this as at the very least it is a great computer science exercise and surely a learning experience for anyone attempting it.

If you continue with your port, you are going to have to face the realization that you will always be behind the Java version in terms of features and compatibility - unless you're able to implement the features every time you see a commit message.

For example, I know that portersteimmer is deprecated by snowball... exist
other classes not worth to port now?

If you don't plan on spending every waking moment porting, why not join forces with the SWIG Lucene folks and interface to that from Delphi?


Something else I must know? The code is based in Lucene 1.4.3...

You're already behind and there has been dramatic changes with the latest codebase that will be Lucene 1.9/2.0.


        Erik


--------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Reply via email to