James Ward wrote:
> So can JBoss avoid these issues by just not being J2EE branded or
> "certified"?

J2EE is a trademark of Sun, in the field of application servers.
Suns official policy on their trademarks can be found at
http://www.sun.com/policies/trademarks/, but it is important to
view this policy in the light of trademark law in general and Suns
view of the JBoss project in particular.

The trademark status of J2EE means that nobody may use the J2EE mark
when they sell their application server, unless Sun has given
permission for it.
But it is still permissible to use terms like "J2EE-compatible" or
"conforming to Suns J2EE(TM) specification".

It is important that Sun defends any possible infringement of their
trademarks, or they risk loosing them.
Some time back, JBoss was under the name EJBoss. Sun didn't like
this, as the three-letter combination "EJB" is another trademark
of Sun. When Sun told us this, we changed the name, thus showing
Sun that we _do_ respect their trademarks.

While somewhat unofficial (and thus hard to tell for sure), I think
that there is a very good relationship between Sun and the JBoss
project.


As for the Lutris case, it seems to me that Lutris has had trouble
selling their application server because people could download it
at no cost. So they pulled their sources, saying it was temporary
while reorganizing them. But "temporary" cannot go on forever, and
now that they need another excuse they try blaming Sun, saying that
Suns licencing makes it impossible release an Open Source
J2EE-compatible application server.
But it is a bad excuse: Neither copyright law nor trademark law can
stop anybody from independently creating a compatible product.

If I was one of the developers that have contributed their hard work
to the Enhydra application server, I would be p*ssed, since the
Enhydra license allows Lutris to do this.
Fortunately this is not possible with JBoss, as it is under the LGPL
license.


Best Regards,

Ole Husgaard.

_______________________________________________
Jboss-development mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/jboss-development

Reply via email to