I looked into Castor a little bit more today... specificially trying to 
see if there was and documented way to treat a block of xml as a type. 
 It does not appear to be the case... which does not really surprise me. 
 I started looking for other such JAXB|Castor-like things, but I 
stopped, thinking that most tools will do the same.

I suppose we could implement something like Ant, to use reflection to 
create a model from XML... but perhaps there is an easier way?  I think 
there is, not with out issues, but a better way to handle this.

Embedding an XML snippet is really easy, but makes it rather impossible 
to define a schema for the service.xml files (perhaps there is some 
schema directive for this, I don't know... so I am going on what I do 
know).  I sugest that a better aproache would be to configure the 
snippet from a URL.

I personally would like to find a way to keep the snippet, but I think 
that we may be better off using someone else's xml->object generator and 
providing a schema to validate the xml against.

The obvious draw back to this is, well, more files.  Though not a huge 
number of files.  For .sar usage, the resource:// protocol can be used 
to pull out a config from the containing file.  Target components would 
then take that url and unmarshal there configuraion model from it (and 
then invoke the proper configure method with that model, so xml is not 
required to configure) or they can simply parse it and get an Element.

It seems like this is the simplest way to get to non-xml specific 
configuration by using thirdparty tools.

The downside is more files... which sucks, but I think that we can 
probably make that a mute point with the adition of an easy to use 
configuration manager service.  Which would basically hide all of the 
details of files behind a simple web interface, thus allowing ease of 
configuration, by simulating xml snippets in a webpage, but underneith 
managing some files.  That I will leave for future descussion... as the 
usage of NetBoot becomes more common place for large distributions of 
JBoss nodes something like this will really blow peoples minds...

--jason


_______________________________________________
Jboss-development mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/jboss-development

Reply via email to