Isn't "THE BEST" determined in this case by user votes... so it is always going to be scewed twords the varing oppion of the subset of actual users of the product who took the time to vote, and more so by the people who registered the product for voting in the first place.
"THE BEST" has different meaning to different people who have different needs and different design goals. There is never going to be a product labled "THE BEST" which will fit neatly into each possible usage. It is a genaral term which shows that out of the voting polutation, they believe that out of the candidates, JBoss is "THE BEST". People will have to use the product to really understand and evaluate how it fits their needs. Anyone who is going about designing a product based soly on "THE BEST" of any category without taking into account their needs and requirements is already on the road to failure. Lets get on with life, get back to work and stop this annoying thread. --jason Yannick Menager wrote: > Yes, of course it depends it the company's requirement, and also on > the design of the system. If the whole architecture is screwed up, no > matter how good the application server is, it won't cut it. And off > course JBoss has a major price advantage ( My own company's servers > are running on JBoss 2.4.4 on linux, and I'm the one who put them > there, but my company's requirements are not the same my company's > customers... ). The problem is that from what I got from the whole > article, is that it doesn't just say JBoss is a very good app server, > it says it's THE BEST .... I quote ' > Though a free offering, JBoss quashes the old adage that "you get what > you pay for. > > to me IMO that sounds like saying that JBoss can do everything all the > other app servers can do, which is not the case, and not just talking > of the clustering capacities, for example > Certificate based authentication for the web server doesn't seem to > work as far as I could find. Maybe that is not the message that was > being attempted to be sent, but I believe that's the message the whole > thing sent through. Like I mentioned in the other email, it's a > question of expectations. and that kind of award bumps up ALOT > people's expectation alot. And when it comes to this kind of products, > you don't get many chances to win people's hearts. If you burn them > once, you probably won't manage to ever convince them to even bother > trying again. If that award had been for 3.0, It would have been quite > ok, but 2.4 ..... erm... > > > Luke Taylor wrote: > >> Yannick Menager wrote: >> > >> ... >> >>> But saying that JBoss can do everything a commercial appserver like >>> wls, is to raise expectations in such a way that it can actually >>> harm JBoss.... If some people have high requirements in terms of >>> scalability and fault tolerance, and decide to use JBoss after >>> seeing this article, they'll run in big trouble when they find out >>> the differences. >> >> >> >> I disagree here too. In my experince many clients find out exactly >> the opposite - that they've been sold a huge capacity, >> "dual-clustered-weblogic-on-sun-E999999-boxes-with-replicated-oracle-db >> " setup for a system that could be run on a single decent specced box >> running open source server software for a *miniscule* fraction of the >> price, usually because of the vested interests/commission of the >> software companies they were dealing with. >> >> Nobody should deploy on anything unless they've done realistic tests >> of the system with a realisitic simulation of the expected load. They >> should evaluate JBoss the same as any other server - if it fits their >> needs then they save a packet. >> >> Luke. >> >> > > > > _________________________________________________________ > Do You Yahoo!? > Get your free @yahoo.com address at http://mail.yahoo.com > > > _______________________________________________ > Jboss-development mailing list > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/jboss-development _______________________________________________ Jboss-development mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/jboss-development
