Ambani CBI Criminal Case Closed, Gas Price Doubled 
 
Now that Mukesh Ambani and Anil Ambani don’t need Manmohan Singh after getting 
Criminal Case dropped and Getting Double Gas Price than contracted even as 
petroleum prices are down to $40 per barrel, they are now luring Narendra Modi 
for their next con program. 
 
Like a professional criminals they know Manmohan Singh can’t bite any more so 
they decided to “Buy Narendra Modi Silence” on the twin issues. 
 
In both cases consumers of India were and would be cheated. 
 
Ravinder Singh
January16, 2009 
 
CBI to close RCOM case 
 
TOI Delhi January14, 2009 P-28


New Delhi: After spending three years probing if Reliance Infocomm masked 
international calls as domestic ones through auto call-rerouting, the CBI 
appears all set to close the case as it could not make any headway. 

   Though CBI spokesman Harsh Bahal said “matter was still under 
investigation,” sources in the agency said a closure report had been finalised 
as it was not possible for the CBI to probe into the case any further. After a 
year-long preliminary enquiry, CBI registered a formal case in September 2006 
against four top former officials of Reliance Infocomm (now renamed Reliance 
Communications) and unknown BSNL officials for “masking” global calls as local 
ones. PTI 
 




Govt reverses stand on KG gas pricing for NTPC




STATE- RUN NTPC would not be allowed to buy KG- D6 gas at less than $ 4.20 per 
million British thermal unit ( mmBtu), the union government told the Bombay 
High Court on Monday.
 
The high court is hearing a dispute between Mukesh Ambani- led Reliance 
Industries ( RIL) and Anil Ambani’s Reliance Natural Resources ( RNRL) over a 
gas sale agreement, in which the government has intervened.
 
Additional solicitor general Mohan Parasaran told the court that NTPC will not 
be allowed to buy gas at less than $ 4.2 per mmBtu as the power ministry will 
have to go by the decision of the empowered group of ministers on the issue.
 
The power ministry has been backing NTPC as the power utility comes under the 
administrative control. He also said that the gas should be sold as per the 
marketing priorities as spelt out in the gas utilisation policy of the 
government.
NTPC has filed a separate suit against RIL, seeking that RIL execute the 
contract of gas supply. RIL, on the other hand claims that the contract with 
NTPC was not formalised.
 
According to the NTPC- RIL contract, NTPC is due to get the gas from KG basin 
at $ 2.34 mmBtu.
 
RNRL has also staked a claim to get the gas get the gas from RIL at the same 
price as NTPC as part of the family settlement of the two brothers reached over 
the division of the business empire earlier run by their father Dhirubhai 
Ambani. The hearing in RIL- RNRL case will continue.
 
The government had suddenly decided to withdraw from the case between the two 
brothers last month in order to expedite the proceedings so that a settlement 
could reach earlier and the gas flows out of the field to the power plants and 
fertiliser units.
 
HC asks govt to clarify stand on RIL gas pricing 
 
Our Bureau MUMBAI ET January13, 2009 Delhi P-4

   THE Bombay High Court on Monday asked the government to clarify the price at 
which gas from Reliance Industries’ Krishna-Godavari basin off the east coast 
would be sold to state-owned power generating company NTPC. The government will 
file its reply on Tuesday. 

   A division bench of the court comprising Justice J N Patel and Justice K K 
Tated asked for a clarification from government counsel Mohan Parasaran on this 
aspect while hearing the legal dispute between Mukesh Ambani-led RIL and Anil 
Ambani group firm Reliance Natural Resources (RNRL). The agreement between RIL 
and RNRL was based on a similar contract between RIL and NTPC. The government 
is an intervener in the RIL-RNRL case. 

   “NTPC has yet to come for government approval (for the NTPC-RIL gas deal). 
We will ensure a level playing field,” Mr Parasaran said. 

   RIL had agreed to supply 12 million metric standard cubic meters per day 
(mmscmd) of gas to NTPC at $2.34 per mmbtu for 17 years. The price is, however, 
subject to government approval. 

   Mr Parasaran said the sale price of $4.2 per unit of natural gas from the KG 
basin, which was determined by an Empowered Group of Ministers (EGoM), would be 
applicable to all buyers, including government companies and private firms. 

   Reacting to Monday’s court proceedings, RIL counsel Harish Salve told ET: 
“It’s good for us, if the court lifts stay and directs RIL to sell gas to a 
government company. We can sell entire KG basin gas to Gail, for example, at 
$4.2 per mmbtu. RIL’s $10 billion is stuck in the KG basin project. We need to 
recover the money.” 

   If the EGoM decision on gas pricing turns out to be applicable to NTPC, the 
country’s largest power producer may have to fork out $4.2 per mmbtu, almost 
double of what it had agreed with RIL. This would translate a total loss of Rs 
24,000 crore over 17 years. A press release from the EGoM issued on the day the 
price of $4.20 was decided said the number was “without prejudice” to the 
RILRNRL and RIL-NTPC court cases”. 

   NTPC is fighting a separate legal battle with Reliance Industries in the 
Bombay High Court. NTPC’s allegation is that RIL did not honour the gas 
agreement it had signed. 
 
HC asks govt to clarify stand on RIL gas pricing 
 
Our Bureau MUMBAI ET January13, 2009 Delhi P-4

   THE Bombay High Court on Monday asked the government to clarify the price at 
which gas from Reliance Industries’ Krishna-Godavari basin off the east coast 
would be sold to state-owned power generating company NTPC. The government will 
file its reply on Tuesday. 

   A division bench of the court comprising Justice J N Patel and Justice K K 
Tated asked for a clarification from government counsel Mohan Parasaran on this 
aspect while hearing the legal dispute between Mukesh Ambani-led RIL and Anil 
Ambani group firm Reliance Natural Resources (RNRL). The agreement between RIL 
and RNRL was based on a similar contract between RIL and NTPC. The government 
is an intervener in the RIL-RNRL case. 

   “NTPC has yet to come for government approval (for the NTPC-RIL gas deal). 
We will ensure a level playing field,” Mr Parasaran said. 

   RIL had agreed to supply 12 million metric standard cubic meters per day 
(mmscmd) of gas to NTPC at $2.34 per mmbtu for 17 years. The price is, however, 
subject to government approval. 

   Mr Parasaran said the sale price of $4.2 per unit of natural gas from the KG 
basin, which was determined by an Empowered Group of Ministers (EGoM), would be 
applicable to all buyers, including government companies and private firms. 

   Reacting to Monday’s court proceedings, RIL counsel Harish Salve told ET: 
“It’s good for us, if the court lifts stay and directs RIL to sell gas to a 
government company. We can sell entire KG basin gas to Gail, for example, at 
$4.2 per mmbtu. RIL’s $10 billion is stuck in the KG basin project. We need to 
recover the money.” 

   If the EGoM decision on gas pricing turns out to be applicable to NTPC, the 
country’s largest power producer may have to fork out $4.2 per mmbtu, almost 
double of what it had agreed with RIL. This would translate a total loss of Rs 
24,000 crore over 17 years. A press release from the EGoM issued on the day the 
price of $4.20 was decided said the number was “without prejudice” to the 
RILRNRL and RIL-NTPC court cases”. 

   NTPC is fighting a separate legal battle with Reliance Industries in the 
Bombay High Court. NTPC’s allegation is that RIL did not honour the gas 
agreement it had signed. 
 
 
 
 


      

Reply via email to