[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KAFKA-16511 ]
Francois Visconte deleted comment on KAFKA-16511: ------------------------------------------- was (Author: JIRAUSER288982): Here is for example on one of the partition where I have the issue: {code} _zIcSPWGzlqLjUTFfw}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_STARTED, eventTimestampMs=1712036488994, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 432066, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=YTIk_zIcSPWGzlqLjUTFfw}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_FINISHED, eventTimestampMs=1712036489094, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 432319, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=8mQ_JJLfTQmkP80MYcN6Ig}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_STARTED, eventTimestampMs=1712038114012, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 432320, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=8mQ_JJLfTQmkP80MYcN6Ig}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_FINISHED, eventTimestampMs=1712038114110, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 432593, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=oqr_-KDrSIGiGrcLQZhzvA}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_STARTED, eventTimestampMs=1712039805803, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 432594, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=oqr_-KDrSIGiGrcLQZhzvA}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_FINISHED, eventTimestampMs=1712039805901, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 432914, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=OSou-FH9S4ioH5LHYUxPMg}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_STARTED, eventTimestampMs=1712041682856, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 432915, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=OSou-FH9S4ioH5LHYUxPMg}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_FINISHED, eventTimestampMs=1712041683023, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 433251, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=uSPj4yS5RIO1LuBHecl7iQ}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_STARTED, eventTimestampMs=1712043678337, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 433252, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=uSPj4yS5RIO1LuBHecl7iQ}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_FINISHED, eventTimestampMs=1712043678474, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 433577, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=pcCt8vc-TUyRhHOGUJBHXg}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_STARTED, eventTimestampMs=1712045569214, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 433578, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=pcCt8vc-TUyRhHOGUJBHXg}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_FINISHED, eventTimestampMs=1712045569333, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 433904, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=LFqoPyg0SOiHbscnV3Ahtw}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_STARTED, eventTimestampMs=1712047491475, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 433905, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=LFqoPyg0SOiHbscnV3Ahtw}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_FINISHED, eventTimestampMs=1712047491576, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 434229, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=SSyS_hbXSEKD5rgbu1S8ug}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_STARTED, eventTimestampMs=1712049443915, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 434230, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=SSyS_hbXSEKD5rgbu1S8ug}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_FINISHED, eventTimestampMs=1712049444048, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 434584, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=ywQr_XFJSMiUnC4jZcQcxw}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_STARTED, eventTimestampMs=1712051556351, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 434585, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=ywQr_XFJSMiUnC4jZcQcxw}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_FINISHED, eventTimestampMs=1712051556465, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 434901, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=5_3z-dusQEeSDqNC_E5ifQ}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_STARTED, eventTimestampMs=1712053602489, brokerId=10041} partition: 12, offset: 434902, value: RemoteLogSegmentMetadataUpdate{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic2-774, id=5_3z-dusQEeSDqNC_E5ifQ}, customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=DELETE_SEGMENT_FINISHED, eventTimestampMs=1712053602602, brokerId=10041} {code} > Leaking tiered segments > ----------------------- > > Key: KAFKA-16511 > URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KAFKA-16511 > Project: Kafka > Issue Type: Bug > Components: Tiered-Storage > Affects Versions: 3.7.0 > Reporter: Francois Visconte > Assignee: Kamal Chandraprakash > Priority: Major > Labels: tiered-storage > > I have some topics there were not written since a few days (having 12h > retention) where some data remains on tiered storage (in our case S3) and > they are never deleted. > > Looking at the log history, it appears that we never even tried to delete > these segments: > When looking at one of the non-leaking segment, I get the following > interesting messages: > > {code:java} > "2024-04-02T10:30:45.265Z","""kafka""","""10039""","[RemoteLogManager=10039 > partition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic1_3543-764] Deleted remote log segment > RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic1_3543-764, > id=fqGng3UURCG3-v4lETeLKQ} due to leader-epoch-cache truncation. Current > earliest-epoch-entry: EpochEntry(epoch=8, startOffset=2980106), > segment-end-offset: 2976819 and segment-epochs: [5]" > "2024-04-02T10:30:45.242Z","""kafka""","""10039""","Deleting log segment data > for completed successfully > RemoteLogSegmentMetadata{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId > {topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic1_3543-764, > id=fqGng3UURCG3-v4lETeLKQ} > , startOffset=2968418, endOffset=2976819, brokerId=10029, > maxTimestampMs=1712009754536, eventTimestampMs=1712013411147, > segmentLeaderEpochs={5=2968418}, segmentSizeInBytes=536351075, > customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=COPY_SEGMENT_FINISHED}" > "2024-04-02T10:30:45.144Z","""kafka""","""10039""","Deleting log segment data > for RemoteLogSegmentMetadata{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId > {topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic1_3543-764, > id=fqGng3UURCG3-v4lETeLKQ} > , startOffset=2968418, endOffset=2976819, brokerId=10029, > maxTimestampMs=1712009754536, eventTimestampMs=1712013411147, > segmentLeaderEpochs={5=2968418}, segmentSizeInBytes=536351075, > customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=COPY_SEGMENT_FINISHED}" > "2024-04-01T23:16:51.157Z","""kafka""","""10029""","[RemoteLogManager=10029 > partition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic1_3543-764] Copied > 00000000000002968418.log to remote storage with segment-id: > RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic1_3543-764, > id=fqGng3UURCG3-v4lETeLKQ}" > "2024-04-01T23:16:51.147Z","""kafka""","""10029""","Copying log segment data > completed successfully, metadata: > RemoteLogSegmentMetadata{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId > {topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic1_3543-764, > id=fqGng3UURCG3-v4lETeLKQ} > , startOffset=2968418, endOffset=2976819, brokerId=10029, > maxTimestampMs=1712009754536, eventTimestampMs=1712013397319, > segmentLeaderEpochs={5=2968418}, segmentSizeInBytes=536351075, > customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=COPY_SEGMENT_STARTED}" > "2024-04-01T23:16:37.328Z","""kafka""","""10029""","Copying log segment data, > metadata: RemoteLogSegmentMetadata{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId > {topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic1_3543-764, > id=fqGng3UURCG3-v4lETeLKQ} > , startOffset=2968418, endOffset=2976819, brokerId=10029, > maxTimestampMs=1712009754536, eventTimestampMs=1712013397319, > segmentLeaderEpochs={5=2968418}, segmentSizeInBytes=536351075, > customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=COPY_SEGMENT_STARTED}" > {code} > > Which looks right because we can see logs from both the plugin and remote log > manager indicating that the remote log segment was removed. > Now if I look on one of the leaked segment, here is what I see > > {code:java} > "2024-04-02T00:43:33.834Z","""kafka""","""10001""","[RemoteLogManager=10001 > partition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic1_3543-765] Copied > 00000000000002971163.log to remote storage with segment-id: > RemoteLogSegmentId{topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic1_3543-765, > id=8dP13VDYSaiFlubl9SNBTQ}" > "2024-04-02T00:43:33.822Z","""kafka""","""10001""","Copying log segment data > completed successfully, metadata: > RemoteLogSegmentMetadata{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId > {topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic1_3543-765, > id=8dP13VDYSaiFlubl9SNBTQ} > , startOffset=2971163, endOffset=2978396, brokerId=10001, > maxTimestampMs=1712010648756, eventTimestampMs=1712018599981, > segmentLeaderEpochs={7=2971163}, segmentSizeInBytes=459778940, > customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=COPY_SEGMENT_STARTED}" > "2024-04-02T00:43:20.003Z","""kafka""","""10001""","Copying log segment data, > metadata: RemoteLogSegmentMetadata{remoteLogSegmentId=RemoteLogSegmentId > {topicIdPartition=5G8Ai8kBSwmQ3Ln4QRY5rA:topic1_3543-765, > id=8dP13VDYSaiFlubl9SNBTQ} > , startOffset=2971163, endOffset=2978396, brokerId=10001, > maxTimestampMs=1712010648756, eventTimestampMs=1712018599981, > segmentLeaderEpochs={7=2971163}, segmentSizeInBytes=459778940, > customMetadata=Optional.empty, state=COPY_SEGMENT_STARTED}" > > {code} > I have no errors whatsoever indicating that the remote log deletion was > actually triggered and failed. > I tried rolling restarting my cluster to see if refreshing remote log > metadata from fresh state would help but that did not help. Removing segments > in tiered storage and restarting brokers after did not help either. > Now if I use offset shell to get earliest and latest offsets for both > partitions > > {code:java} > $ /opt/kafka-3.7.0/bin/kafka-get-offsets.sh --bootstrap-server > $KAFKA_CONNECT_STR --topic topic1 --partitions 764,765 - > -time -2 > raw_spans_datadog_3543:764:2980106 > raw_spans_datadog_3543:765:2976337 > $ $ /opt/kafka-3.7.0/bin/kafka-get-offsets.sh --bootstrap-server > $KAFKA_CONNECT_STR --topic topic1 --partitions 764,765 --time -1 > raw_spans_datadog_3543:764:2980106 > raw_spans_datadog_3543:765:2978397 > {code} > We can see that despite the retention period being largely exceeded, there > are 2060 offsets that are never expiring. > One thing that might have triggered this bug was the fact that some nodes > were replaced with fresh disk in between the segment creation and their > expiration. > The issue happened on 418 partitions out of 4513, ~9% of partitions. -- This message was sent by Atlassian Jira (v8.20.10#820010)