at 9:50 am EDT on (Wednesday) 29 October 2003 Herbert J. Bernstein said: > There are two major problems in basing revisions to Jmol on Chime-related > material: > > 1. The general body of law protecting intellectual property. > 2. The license that everyone who uses Chime agreed to > > Now, unless someone has a very large pot of money to mount a spirited > legal fight to carve out whatever exceptions can be carved out to > get around these problems, the best course forward is to steer clear > of basing anything that is intended to be open source on anything > in any way derived from Chime as opposed to being derived from RasMol, > except to the extent that MDL provides written permission. >
someone feel free to correct me, but... I can't think of any feature implemented in Chime that does not already exist in one or many other software titles. I don't see how MDL could step forward and purport that they own the ideas of molecular surfaces, timed delays, and object position tweening, even though these features are the key differences between RasMol and Chime. these are neither Chime derivatives nor original MDL ideas. as long as JMol does not delve into the Chime source to find out how they do these things, I can't seriously see any infringement issues based on their EUL. the implementation of them in Chime is MDL property, but the concepts themselves are not. but to sidestep the entire issue, I think the way Chime handles movement and time is not user-friendly. I would like to see JMol handle it differently, something more in line with the average user's mental image of a movie. then a chime2jmol.pl type of converter could make short work of any compatibility issues. if JMol could offer features like tweening and key frames, for example, that would be a wonderful paradigm shift in molecular animations. regards, :tim -- timothy driscoll molvisions - molecular graphics & visualization <http://www.molvisions.com/> usa:north carolina:wake forest ------------------------------------------------------- This SF.net email is sponsored by: SF.net Giveback Program. Does SourceForge.net help you be more productive? Does it help you create better code? SHARE THE LOVE, and help us help YOU! Click Here: http://sourceforge.net/donate/ _______________________________________________ Jmol-users mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/jmol-users

