> You have the option to show selectionHalos for visible atoms only.
> I think it is
> set showHiddenSelectionHalos
> (normally FALSE)

Yes, you are right. The hidden selection halos are not shown by default.
Good. But lets take a specific example. Barium Hollandite is a simple
channel structure, with the channels occupied by Ba.
http://icsd.ill.eu/icsd/index.php?action=Search&authors=Cheary&mineral=hollandite.
Again, click on the "Demo" option in the pop-up and then on the formula
Ba1.242 (Al2.484 Ti5.516) O16 to draw the structure

Now if I open a Jmol console and write:
selectionHalos ON; select _Ba
ALL barium atoms are selected, hidden or not. Good. And if I write:
selectionHalos ON; select _Ba and VISIBLE
I can restrict the selection to the visible atoms. Good again.

Now look at the difference between these two situations if I follow with:

if(selectionHalos){{selected}.property_hide=1};selectionHalos OFF;select
all and visible;isosurface cavity resolution 2.0 ignore(property_hide=1)
minset 5 cavity 0.4 sasurface 0.15;color isosurface blue fullylit

In the first case, with all hidden Ba selected, full channels are drawn.
In the second case, only closed blobs are drawn - the channels are
truncated because of the presence of the hidden Ba atoms :-(

Now I want to do this with picking, but:
set picking SELECT SITE;
(exceptionally) implies VISIBLE. What I would like is:
set picking SELECT SITE ALL;
with the qualifier "ALL" to select both visible and invisible sites.

I know that I originally suggested that SELECT SITE be restricted to
visible by default, but it is still exceptional that only SITE and ELEMENT
are restricted to VISIBLE:
http://chemapps.stolaf.edu/jmol/docs/index.htm?ver=11.8#setpicking

> I'm not understanding why this has to be done by physically clicking...
> If so, then it's just some sort of short script, I think.

Yes, I can do it as above with "selectionHalos ON; select _Ba" but I want
the user to be able to select with the mouse the sites he wants excluded
from the calculation of the isosurface (which is otherwise a really nice
tool to answer the question "what volume is available for those atoms")

Alan.

Robert Hanson said:
> On Sun, Mar 14, 2010 at 9:49 AM, Alan Hewat <[email protected]> wrote:
>
>> Bob has immediately corrected this problem with isosurfaces for large
>> numbers of invisible atoms in 11.9.33_dev. It works perfectly. Many
>> thanks.
>>
>> Now I have an associated question :-) Why is the qualifier "VISIBLE"
>> imposed for "set picking SELECT" with SITE and ELEMENT ? I understand
>> that you don't normally want to draw selection halos around invisible
>> atoms, but sometimes when you select a site, you do want the selection
>> to apply to ALL equivalent sites, even those that are invisible.
>>
> The idea was simply that when one is picking atoms, it is only the visible
> ones that you are selecting. There could be any number of models present
 > but not visible, and it would not make sense to be selecting SITEs or
> ELEMENTs from unrelated structures (for example, in multi-structure CIF
> files. So all the set picking select options work only on the visible
> atom set.
>
> You can always set up a pick callback so that you can expand the
> selection, I think.
>
> Why ? In ICSD I select sites that I want to exclude from the construction
>> of isosurfaces and label them with a property. For example, I want to
>> exclude extraneous atoms occupying sites in zeolite channels so that I
>> can draw the channel isosurface. But I don't know how to select the
>> equivalent invisible sites, and this results in isosurfaces limited by
>> those invisible occupied sites.
>
> I'm not understanding why this has to be done by physically clicking on
> atoms, but in any case, you must be processing the selections specially,
> right? The user clicks on an atom, then clicks on some other button to
> create the isosurface?
> If so, then it's just some sort of short script, I think.
>
>> A simple extension might be: "set picking SELECT SITE ALL" which would
>> preserve the "VISIBLE" implied by "set picking SELECT SITE". (But
>> perhaps there is an existing alternative to achieve that?)
>
> you mean, I think, "NOT preserve..." there?
>
>> To avoid selection halos being drawn around invisible atoms, you could
>> allow an explicit VISIBLE qualifier i.e. "selectionHalos ON VISIBLE".
>>
> You have the option to show selectionHalos for visible atoms only. I think
> it is
> set showHiddenSelectionHalos
> (normally FALSE)
>
>> The point is that sometimes you want to select even the invisible atom
>> sites, but would prefer only the visible atom selection to be hallowed.
>>
> I think you need to do this in code, not by some automatic method
> involving picking. I'm not sure exactly what the logic would be that you
> are after, but it shouldn't be too complicated.
>
> Something like
>
> for all sites
>   If no atom with this site is visible, then deselect all such atoms,
> visible or not."
>
> Does that sound about right?
>
> Bob
______________________________________________
Dr Alan Hewat, NeutronOptics, Grenoble, FRANCE
<[email protected]> +33.476.98.41.68
      http://www.NeutronOptics.com/hewat
______________________________________________


------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Download Intel&#174; Parallel Studio Eval
Try the new software tools for yourself. Speed compiling, find bugs
proactively, and fine-tune applications for parallel performance.
See why Intel Parallel Studio got high marks during beta.
http://p.sf.net/sfu/intel-sw-dev
_______________________________________________
Jmol-users mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/jmol-users

Reply via email to