Ah-ha! I'd love to know more about the internals at play here, but rearranging the "hide()" and the "appendTo" commands did the trick. For anyone else that might stumble across this thread:
$('<li />') .append( $('<input type="text" />').val(item.a) ) .appendTo('myList').hide() .slideDown() ...works great. Thanks again for all the help! Nate