Hi.

Thank you for confirming.

> I propose 
https://kallithea-scm.org/repos/kallithea-incoming/changeset/dee1b60bad29621882eb769eb5bc8707647ccf1d
 .

As far as I have tried, I believe this change fixes the new owner to operate 
correctly. (Both from the web and from the API.)


> I propose 
https://kallithea-scm.org/repos/kallithea-incoming/changeset/bf7369172810fb1a9452af767a2168edba3dc2f3

I believe that this change is also necessary to properly remove permissions 
from the previous owner.


> Do you see other problems related to these changes? Any other places where 
the code makes incorrect assumptions on repo groups
> and owner / permissions?

Related to the second issue, there seems to be a problem that "the owner (non-super user) of a group cannot set permissions for himself/herself".
In the permission settings screen, the owner cannot set the following write 
permissions for himself/herself.
Any attempt to do so fails with the message 'Cannot revoke permission for 
yourself as admin'.
I think this is part of the behavior that remains from when we were handling explicitly granting administrative privileges to groups.

However, some groups can be modified, and there may be conditions under which 
the above failure occurs.
This may be the case for groups created by ordinary users themselves.


> If you edit a repository group, the permissions tab will describe it as "Write" as 
"(Add repos)". Admin access should not be
> necessary. Please verify that you really see the behaviour you describe.
> (For some reason, repo group creation is more constrained in than repo 
creation... but that's yet another story.)

My apologies.
I meant to write "repository groups" instead of "repository" but I was wrong.

Sometimes I wonder why, because I want to create a group with the following 
structure, but cannot do so with only write permission.

personals         <- Create by admin.
  + userA_group   <- Create by userA.
  + userB_group   <- Create by userB.


Thanks

--
toras9000
_______________________________________________
kallithea-general mailing list
kallithea-general@sfconservancy.org
https://lists.sfconservancy.org/mailman/listinfo/kallithea-general

Reply via email to