https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=409627
--- Comment #6 from Tyson Tan <tysont...@gmail.com> --- (In reply to Tymond from comment #4) > Created attachment 121532 [details] > Screenshot of the workaround + new mode > > This is the result of my work for now. > > On the left, you can see the workaround with a group that has a black layer > on Normal mode (let's call it "workaround middle layer"), then a layer with > the new color in Normal mode (let's call it "workaround top layer"), and > then the whole group is in Addition mode (let's call it "workaround group"). > Right side is my new blending mode. Color values are just the same, I > checked it. > > I have a question how this blending mode should behave while being on a > layer that has a lower opacity than 50%. > > On the right side of the screenshot you can see two rows of smaller > yellowish-whitish circles. The first row is compiled out of 9 circles > painted with 20, 50, 40 etc. to 100% of opacity. The second one is the same > layer, but the opacity of the layer is 50%. As you can see, the brightest > circle on the layer is yellow and looks the same as 50% opacity circle in > the top row. > > On the left side there are two rows under the first "reference" one - first > one is when you lower the opacity of the "workaround top layer" to 50%. The > second one is when you lower the opacity of the "workaround group" to 50%. > The first row has values identical to what you can get in the new blending > mode. The second one is an example of how I can make it behave. > > The question is, whether you think it should behave (after lowering opacity > of the layer) like the second small circle row or like the third one? What > about making a transparency mask? (If I leave it as it is, it will be always > consistent; I'm just not sure if it's what is expected. This is the first > blending mode that uses alpha for something else than just blending two > output colors together, here we calculate the result color using the alpha > value). If you don't have a preference, please tell me so, too. > > Another question: do you have an access to SAI or Photoshop? I need to know > what the value of the color is if you put a layer of color (10, 100, 200) in > 30% and on top of that color (250, 200, 150) in 50% in the Luminosity (SAI) > blending mode. Workaround don't work at all on that example and I think my > blending mode can have "incorrect" colors there. Hi Tymond, Thank you for helping us with the new blending mode! I'm very busy at the moment so I cannot do the tests right away. I did secure access to PS and SAI again, and I will let you know about the result. I cannot fully understand what you were saying by a glance, so please give me some time. -- You are receiving this mail because: You are watching all bug changes.
