https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=420541

--- Comment #6 from Nate Graham <n...@kde.org> ---
What I think we have here is a conflict between the legitimate desire to keep
notifications out of the way and non-annoying with the legitimate desire to
make critical notifications adequately attnetion-getting.

This may seem strange, but anecdotally I have observed users who completely
miss notification pop-ups in the periphery of their screens. This is hard for
me to understand since for me the pop-up is impossible to miss. But I have seen
this happen quite often for my wife (who uses Plasma) and my mother, father,
and sister (who all use MacOS, which has a similar style of pop-up). Raitaro
seems to be experiencing the same issue.

I have never seen this happen for people using Windows 10, which has enormous,
intrusive, stupid-looking pop-ups. But that's not a great solution since then
non-critical pop-ups get in your way and annoy you a ton. It's an
unsatisfactory sledgehammer solution, but it seems to have been specifically
designed to address this, which I think is evidence that it's a legitimate
issue.

Perhaps we can satisfy both parties by keeping non-critical notifications
exactly as they are (small, out of the way, unobtrusive) while somehow
increasing the visual prominence of only critical notifications. I think the
proposed full screen overlay is much too intrusive, but maybe we could consider
some kind of middle ground? Like making the pop-up bigger, or making it wiggle
or giving it a pulsing red border or header or something (just random ideas)?
Critical notifications are the kind of thing you really *do* need to see, read
and acknowledge.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.

Reply via email to