https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=430440
--- Comment #11 from Oded Arbel <o...@geek.co.il> --- (In reply to Gauthier from comment #7) > Should it get marked as resolved? Looking at the MR that was merged, it adds the workaround to the task bar context menu. This issue is about the window operations menu, so the MR does not solve this issue in that it doesn't fix the window operations menu. I'm not sure what is the use case for the task bar right click menu as I almost never use it and there is no keyboard shortcut to get to it. IMHO the window operations menu should be the target for any improved behavior its better accessible by both keyboard and mouse (Fitz law). (In reply to Gauthier from comment #8) > @Oded Have there been any progress on your MR for VDs, and if so, does it > seem likely to also work for activities? I did not move forward with my work on the checkboxed window operations submenus (I'm treating desktops and activities the same for this). I didn't have a lot of time for that, but more than that I'm very confused about the situation - in Kwin Wayland there is a workaround for the desktops menu that is very similar in behavior to https://invent.kde.org/plasma/plasma-desktop/-/merge_requests/231, but not identical, and of course that it wasn't implemented for activities. I think before any additional work is done, there should be some effort to understand what is the UX that we are aiming for and how it should apply to all relevant use cases - wayland, x11, window operations menu, plasma shell task bar menus, activities, desktops, whatever else is relevant. Currently there are too many different behaviors for things that should basically be the same. I'm not sure how/where/when/with who to start such a discussion. On that note, I personally dislike the "dual control" UX that is offered in Wayland windows operation menu and the above mentioned MR: on my systems I have few activities (2 or 3 normally) and many virtual desktops (6 or 8) and while the "checkbox + move to items" is kind of manageable in the activities selection, it is almost unusable for virtual desktops (the wayland window operations desktops menu takes more than half the height of my screen now) - it actually takes noticeable time and thought to locate the menu option I need in order to just move this one window to desktop 4. I believe we can do better, and would like to have a discussion about that. -- You are receiving this mail because: You are watching all bug changes.
