https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=458214
--- Comment #2 from Friedrich W. H. Kossebau <kosse...@kde.org> --- (In reply to Manuel de la Fuente from comment #1) > Created attachment 151929 [details] > List of proposals for the icon > > I've attached a few icons based on the original game assets, with a take on > the current one too (though that one is a bit more rough). Let me know your > thoughts! Yay, happy to see things happening :) First impression thoughts following First though a quick hint that KSokoban might see a rename, due to trademark issues (or respect to those still around who have done and distribute the original game). Yet to be decided & executed. New name should still be around the "dude reshuffling things in warehouse" theme ideally. Interesting idea to switch to using the goal asset as app icon theme. Good: * might reflect more to the game idea to get things to given new locations Bad: * breaks tradition * small shape expansion might look out of proportion * object type hard to identify for those who do not know KSokoban, might result in mental mismapping/confusion Using a green colored gem misses the direct reference for me, as the current game itself does not have such an object appearance. Using a red gem shaped similar to the one in the game actually picks up the tradition of the initial icon, in case you have not yet researched yourself :) (see https://invent.kde.org/games/ksokoban/-/commit/3f1a2d11336c8e175579a8e6019b7074dc5fe3dc ). with the version slightly turned to the viewer matching the original in that. The version matching the current icon looks good. Though as with the current icon, my mind always sees also a boat steering upon me, with a strange deck ;) It surely is unique and by that serves a purpose, but also feels strange. So out of the selection presented, after a first look I would tend to the shape of the two red gems top-left. Though they might perhaps get a tad more 3D effect, like more contrast in whatever way to the sides on the left & the right? The green variants have that better, at least on my display. -- You are receiving this mail because: You are watching all bug changes.
