Thanks for the reply.

Maybe I'm not correctly interpreting the reply referring to "a kernel
issue like this requires kernel bisection" and "We can't do much if we
don't have the hardware".

Why would the internet connectivity issues I'm seeing with Ubuntu 18.04
Server running the Intel onboard i219-v Ethernet adapter be a kernel
issue?

As I've stated multiple times already, this i219-v Ethernet adapter ran
perfectly on CentOS Server 7.4 for over a week (and we know CentOS is
much more conservation with the Linux kernels used in their
distribution) before I removed CentOS 7.4 and decided I'd given Ubuntu
Server 18.04 a try and see where Ubuntu is at as a Linux server
distribution vs CentOS.

Given my experience designing and building $B networks, this is not a
hardware issue (very, very rare) and given CentOS Server 7.4 worked
perfectly for everything expected of a server, including the network
performance using this same i219-v Ethernet adaptor, it's most likely
not a Linux kernel issue.

There's something in the way Ubuntu Server 18.04 is configured to use
this Intel i219-v onboard network adaptor hardware that's the root of
the issue.  It's probably a scenario that Ubuntu Server 18.04 had
probably not seen before and was never verified with (given what I know
and have observed with how software is tested these days.  My vendors
constantly use us as a testing platform, but that's a separate story).

Again today, the network adaptor on the Ubuntu 18.04 server lost
connectivity to the internet and I had to disconnect and then reconnect
the wired Ethernet connnection to get the internet connection backup
(simply, Network Manager service has to be stopped and then restarted,
you can see it clearly in the logs I provided in a previous post).

What is Ubuntu support/development saying here? That Ubuntu Server 18.04
can't execute basic internet connectivity on the i219-v Ethernet adaptor
in a 100% stable manner?

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Kernel
Packages, which is subscribed to linux in Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1785171

Title:
  Intel I219-V Ethernet Interface on Ubuntu Linux Using e1000e Driver
  keeps Dropping Internet Connection

Status in linux package in Ubuntu:
  Incomplete
Status in linux source package in Bionic:
  Incomplete

Bug description:
  I've turned up many, many new server and workstation systems over the
  years on both Linux and Windows. Never seen anything like this
  behaviour I'm witnessing on Ubuntu Server 18.04 before where I simply
  lose Internet connectivity while using a browser.  Ethernet interfaces
  usually either work or they don't work.

  I've configured the Intel I219-V Ethernet interface (wired Ethernet
  connection, there is no wifi on this system) using the e1000e driver
  for Ubuntu.  The Ethernet connection is configured to use
  NetworkManager via Netplan on Ubuntu 18.04 LTS Server version.  ASRock
  Z370m Pro4 motherboard.

  The Ethernet interface will drop the Internet connectivity when I'm
  using either the Firefox or Chrome browser.  It usually happens when
  I'm using the search features of the browser. I can't figure out what
  would cause this type of behaviour.  When the Internet connection
  drops, the only way to get back Internet connectivity is to disconnect
  the wired connection using the Ubuntu features and then re-connect
  (this restarts the NetworkManager service I notice).

  In the NetworkManager logs I do notice an "auth" error about a file or
  directory not found. I've never seen that before.

  Note:  The auth error does not coincide with the loss of Internet
  connectivity, but it does proceed it.  Often there can be many hours
  between the auth error and the actual loss of Internet connectivity.

  After I reconnect the connection (via re-starting the NetworkManager
  service) all will be fine for up to a day or so, but then I stress
  test it with a bunch of searches using the browser and usually I can
  get the Internet connectivity to drop again.  Repeat the disconnect
  and reconnect process again (aka re-start NetworkManager) and the
  Internet connectivity will be fine again.  The longest I've seen it go
  without an "Internet connectivity drop" issue is about 36 hours.

  I notice that the e1000e driver does not list the I219-V as a
  supported Ethernet interface in the Intel documentation for the Linux
  version of the driver.  I'm not sure why that is.  The I219-V is
  supposed to used another driver, but it's not clear there's a Linux
  version for of the driver for the I219-V.

  I'm really disappointed that I've run into this issue with Ubuntu
  Server LTS 18.04 on this motherboard.  I had CentOS Server 7.4 (my
  standard server OS, a great Linux distro) on this same motherboard for
  a week with no issues, so I know the motherboard and the I219-V
  Ethernet interface are 100% good hardware wise and can work properly.
  CentOS 7.4 uses NetworkManager as the default for managing the
  Ethernet interface.

  The only reason I'm using Ubuntu Server 18.04 on this motherboard is
  because of a specific package that Ubuntu has a newer packaged version
  than CentOS. CentOS is extremely stable when it comes to basic server
  functionality.

  Hopefully, this bug with the I219-V Ethernet interface using the
  e1000e drive for Linux can be verified and a fix rolled out.

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux/+bug/1785171/+subscriptions

-- 
Mailing list: https://launchpad.net/~kernel-packages
Post to     : kernel-packages@lists.launchpad.net
Unsubscribe : https://launchpad.net/~kernel-packages
More help   : https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp

Reply via email to