On Mon, Sep 12, 2005 at 02:52:38PM +0100, Hiten Pandya wrote: > Bugzilla is not bad at all for the purpose. It also allows grouping of > bugs, which can be quite useful. Another point is that Bugzilla does not > allow anon entries per e-mail and that's a good thing; we will avoid a lot > of problems by now allowing anonymous mails as followup.
Since I was the person to request the addition of the feature in the comparision, let me plain. I have to report bugs in a great number of projects and having to register first is a major PITA. I don't mind having to use a challenge-respoonse solution for my first mail to a project, but it is much easier to just send an email with the bug report and be done with it. This is very much like how you report bugs to developers directly and a good thing to allow. > We are definitely not going with GNATS, period. Who even suggested to use GNATS? It is in the list for completeness, but not as option. The (mis)handling of attachments is important enough to ignore it. Joerg
