Hi Kazu, Thanks for reviewing the patchset!
On Tue, Sep 14, 2021 at 07:04:24AM +0000, HAGIO KAZUHITO(萩尾 一仁) wrote: > Hi Tao Liu, > > Thanks for the patchset! > > -----Original Message----- > > This patch set adds ZSTD compression support to makedumpfile. With ZSTD > > compression > > support, the vmcore dump size and time consumption can have a better > > balance than > > zlib/lzo/snappy. > > > > How to build: > > > > Build using make: > > $ make USEZSTD=on > > > > Performance Comparison: > > > > How to measure > > > > I took a x86_64 machine which had 4T memory, and the compression level > > range from (-3 to 4) for ZSTD, as well as zlib/lzo/snappy compression. > > All testing was done by makedumpfile single thread mode. > > > > As for compression performance testing, in order to avoid the > > performance > > bottle neck of disk I/O, I used the following makedumpfile cmd, which > > took > > lzo compression as an example. "--dry-run" will not write any data to > > disk, > > "--show-stat" will output the vmcore size after compression, and the > > time > > consumption can be collected from the output logs. > > > > $ makedumpfile -d 0 -l /proc/kcore vmcore --dry-run --show-stat > > > > > > As for decompression performance testing, I only tested the (-d 31) > > case, > > because the vmcore size of (-d 0) case is too big to fit in the disk, in > > addtion, to read a oversized file from disk will encounter the disk I/O > > bottle neck. > > > > I triggered a kernel crash and collected a vmcore. Then I converted the > > vmcore into specific compression format using the following makedumpfile > > cmd, which would get a lzo format vmcore as an example: > > > > $ makedumpfile -l vmcore vmcore.lzo > > > > After all vmcores were ready, I used the following cmd to perform the > > decompression, the time consumption can be collected from the logs. > > > > $ makedumpfile -F vmcore.lzo --dry-run --show-stat > > > > > > Result charts > > > > For compression: > > > > makedumpfile -d31 | makedumpfile -d0 > > Compression time vmcore size | Compression time > > vmcore size > > zstd-3 325.516446 5285179595 | 8205.452248 > > 51715430204 > > zstd-2 332.069432 5319726604 | 8057.381371 > > 51732062793 > > zstd-1 309.942773 5730516274 | 8138.060786 > > 52136191571 > > zstd0 439.773076 4673859661 | 8873.059963 > > 50993669657 > > zstd1 406.68036 4700959521 | 8259.417132 > > 51036900055 > > zstd2 397.195643 4699263608 | 8230.308291 > > 51030410942 > > zstd3 436.491632 4673306398 | 8803.970103 > > 51043393637 > > zstd4 543.363928 4668419304 | 8991.240244 > > 51058088514 > > zlib 561.217381 8514803195 | 14381.755611 > > 78199283893 > > lzo 248.175953 16696411879 | 6057.528781 > > 90020895741 > > snappy 231.868312 11782236674 | 5290.919894 > > 245661288355 > > > > For decompression: > > > > makedumpfile -d31 > > decompress time vmcore size > > zstd-3 477.543396 5289373448 > > zstd-2 478.034534 5327454123 > > zstd-1 459.066807 5748037931 > > zstd0 561.687525 4680009013 > > zstd1 547.248917 4706358547 > > zstd2 544.219758 4704780719 > > zstd3 555.726343 4680009013 > > zstd4 558.031721 4675545933 > > zlib 630.965426 8555376229 > > lzo 427.292107 16849457649 > > snappy 446.542806 11841407957 > > > > Discussion > > > > For zstd range from -3 to 4, compression level 2 (ZSTD_dfast) has > > the best time consumption and vmcore dump size balance. > > Do you have a result of -d 1 compression test? I think -d 0 is not > practical, I would like to see a -d 1 result of such a large vmcore. > No, I haven't tested the -d 1 case. I have returned the machine which used for performance testing, I will borrow and test on it again, please wait for a while... > And just out of curiosity, what version of zstd are you using? > When I tested zstd last time, compression level 1 was faster than 2, iirc. > The OS running on the machine is fedora34, I used its default zstd package, whose version is v1.4.9. > btw, ZSTD_dfast is an enum of ZSTD_strategy, not for compression level? Yes, it's enum of ZSTD_strategy [1]. [1]: https://zstd.docsforge.com/dev/api-documentation/#advanced-compression-api-requires-v140 Thanks, Tao Liu > (no need to update for now, I will review later) > > Thanks, > Kazu > > > > > For zstd2/zlib/lzo/snappy, zstd2 has the smallest vmcore size, also > > the best time consumption and vmcore dump size balance. > > > > Tao Liu (11): > > Add dump header for zstd. > > Add command-line processing for zstd > > Add zstd build support > > Notify zstd unsupporting when disabled > > Add single thread zstd compression processing > > Add parallel threads zstd compression processing > > Add single thread zstd uncompression processing > > Add parallel threads zstd uncompression processing > > Add zstd help message > > Add zstd manual description > > Add zstd README description > > > > Makefile | 5 +++ > > README | 5 ++- > > diskdump_mod.h | 1 + > > makedumpfile.8 | 7 ++-- > > makedumpfile.c | 101 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++---- > > makedumpfile.h | 10 +++++ > > print_info.c | 30 ++++++++++----- > > 7 files changed, 138 insertions(+), 21 deletions(-) > > > > -- > > 2.29.2 > _______________________________________________ kexec mailing list kexec@lists.infradead.org http://lists.infradead.org/mailman/listinfo/kexec
