Hi Daniel Wow! I haven't expected that a configurable default RR limit will be implemented, not that fast, let alone at all ;-)
I am happy with such an option, because it will allow me to omit any $TTL directive in the future, except that I would like to set NS RRs to an TTL of 1 day as an example in '$INCLUE ___NAMESERVERS___' I will wait for the next release (FreeBSD port) and report back, although I am pretty sure that you have tested it already. Kudos, thanks and regards, Michael > On 18. Jul 2024, at 19:41, Daniel Salzman via knot-dns-users > <knot-dns-users@lists.nic.cz> wrote: > > Michael, > > FYI https://gitlab.nic.cz/knot/knot-dns/-/merge_requests/1689 > > I hope this solves your issue. > > Daniel > > On 7/15/24 23:43, Michael Grimm wrote: >> Daniel Salzman via knot-dns-users <knot-dns-users@lists.nic.cz> wrote: >>> I don't understand why it's that important if you can add one TTL directive >>> to the zone? >> Example: >> 1) if one does has X zones to configure. >> 2) now, one needs to modify TTL for all zones to whatever reason. >> 3) given that one uses a $INCLUDE ___TTL___ directive in all those X zone >> files … >> 4) one would need to modifying *one* file only instead of X! >> I did expect knot's parser to follow *my* intended directive to follow that >> (POLA). >> But that is not the case, as I found out and why I started this thread. >> It is not of utmost importance, though. >> *But* it would make my setup much easier to administer. >> A configurable default RR limit instead of hardcoded 3600 seconds would help >> as well. >> Regards, >> Michael >>> >>> Daniel >>> >>> Dne 2024-07-15 23:07, Michael Grimm napsal: >>>> Daniel Salzman via knot-dns-users <knot-dns-users@lists.nic.cz> wrote: >>>>> It's a hardcoded default of 3600 seconds. >>>> Ah, now I understand. >>>>> We could simply change the parser to keep the default TTL set within an >>>>> included zone file. However, it seems that Bind >>>>> parses the zone in the same way as Knot. So it's a tough decision :-) >>>> :-) >>>> Or make that hardcoded 3600s a configurable option in knot.conf … >>>> Regards, >>>> Michael >>> -- > -- --
