My email set up does not allow me to trim off old posts, so I am having to
start a fresh email.
Rosemary,
I agree wholeheartedly with this statement, you expressed my
feelings well: "I think its just a sad fact that given the group of people
involved, the lace will never be treated as authentically or thoroughly as
the garment construction and embroidery, even though it was such an
important embellishment at the time. "
My sense of sadness and frustration after opening the book yesterday
was very profound. It is coming from an emotional gut place, not thoughts
involving logic. I can recall them saying book 2 was already finished, I
just expected they would do better editing. None of us is able to put out
mistake free literature, but I am of the opinion we should do the best we
can at the time. The research is ever changing and it is so important to
acknowledge what has changed and why. There just isn't room to put out
badly done work.
With that said, I agree it is good they pulled the bad diagrams and
whatever else was there rather than printing it. Pragmatically speaking, I
would prefer they print nothing about the lace rather than give incorrect
information. Because of the accuracy of their other work and their
general reputation, I would be afraid most people picking up the book
trusted the lace was accurate. I am personally not at a point of feeling
glad about it, though. I had higher expectations from the V&A, especially
when you brought this to their attention after the first book.
In this period of dress, especially, the garments were quite a canvas
for the embellishments such as embroidery, lace, passaments, buttons, etc.
You said, "Ive often observed that there is something about bobbin
lace in particular, that makes many museum curators uneasy because it is a
complicated subject and they just dont understand it." I have
experienced this myself at the major museum in my area. They have a lovely
lace collection, but there is no one on staff that knows about lace
currently, so they will not show it. I have been slowly developing a
polite relationship with them for about 8 years now, being careful not to
sound critical of how things are categorized in their system. I think this
is a place that, as lacemakers, we can all do our part. Coming across
harshly only perpetuates the fear, and I think it is very important not to
do this.
Kim
-
To unsubscribe send email to [email protected] containing the line:
unsubscribe lace [email protected]. For help, write to
[email protected]. Photo site:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/lacemaker/sets/