<<By the way, I'm quoting correspondence from several lace book  authors and
one major book publisher regarding writing a positive review in  return for
having their book(s) in the library.>>
 
If the book has been given in  return for writing a positive review, 
shouldn't there be a disclaimer? I have  always been under the impression that 
the 
review was being written for the  benefit of those subscribing to the 
magazine, not as a "paid" advertisement  intended to benefit the author and 
possibly the club library. If those people  who pay for the magazine are not 
the 
intended beneficiaries of the review then  they should realize this. In 
fact, perhaps the review should appear on a page  designated for advertisements 
or the editor could "box" the review, with a  notation that "this positive 
review was written in return for a copy of the book  to be put in our librar
y".
 
Arguably, a book donated with the explicit requirement of a  positive 
review should be returned, unread, to the author or major book  publisher with 
a 
note about the journalistic integrity of the publication.  Otherwise the 
readers of the publication have no reason to believe any of the  reviews. The 
ruse of trading a book for a positive review only works when the  readership 
thinks the process isn't rigged. The reader places greater  trust in the 
review than in an advertisement because they  believe a review is impartial and 
written for the benefit of the  reader. An advertisement has less impact.
 
When the author suggests that the book is being donated in  return for a 
positive review, the answer should be, "We cannot promise a  positive review. 
Do you want us to return the book, or would you like us to  review it?" I 
would imagine most authors would prefer to have the free exposure  of the book 
in the content area of the magazine rather than none, as in  "there is no 
such thing as bad publicity." Even a negative review often  contains 
information in it that may signal that the book would be of  interest to some 
readers. Likewise, the presence of the book in the library is a  form of 
exposure 
in that it allows readers to evaluate it themselves and buy it  if they 
think it suits their needs. 
 
Of course, if the author doesn't want to take the chance of a  poor review, 
but does want to inform the lace community of the  book's existence, there 
is always the option of paying for an  advertisement, properly understood to 
be an advertisement, instead.
 
If people think that the content of the magazine is not  being written for 
the benefit of the readers why would they pay to  subscribe to the magazine? 
You don't pay to subscribe to an advertising  circular.
 
Devon

-
To unsubscribe send email to [email protected] containing the line:
unsubscribe lace [email protected]. For help, write to
[email protected]. Photo site:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/lacemaker/sets/

Reply via email to