I saw the original note from Charles Baker which mentioned the 2002 issue of
Linux Journal about setting up a wireless home network.  Unfortunately, the
article is only available to subscribers. So here goes...

Is there a difference in the security arrangement at the point in between
the wireless access point and the client in the two scenarios below?  It
would seem that in the scenario A, implementing the VPN gateway with
FreeS/WAN at the LRP box secures you from the point of the company VPN to
the LRP router.  However, once inside your LAN, the data that is transmitted
between the wireless access point and the client is no longer secure (no
encryption provided by the VPN).

In scenario B, it would seem that because you are masquerading to the point
of the client, the data will be encrypted over the wireless network for the
entire length of transmission from the company VPN to the end point at the
client.

Granted, you can implement further security measures over your wireless LAN,
but leaving that out of the discussion, does scenario B offer more
protection?  Is there a fallacy in my thought process here and that scenario
B is just as vulnerable?  Could it be that hacker tools like Airsnort and
WEPcrack can still decrypt the data?


Scenario A
  ________                  _____      ________         _______
 |        |                |     |    |Wireless|       |       |
 |Company |___(Internet)___| LRP |____| Access |__///__|Client |
 |  VPN   |   (        )   | VPN |    |  Point |       |_______|
 |________|                |_____|    |________|


Scenario B
  ________                  ______     ________         _______
 |        |                | LRP  |   |Wireless|       |       |
 |Company |___(Internet)___|IPSec |___| Access |__///__|Client |
 |  VPN   |   (        )   | Masq |   |  Point |       |VPN End|
 |________|                |______|   |________|       |_______|


_______________________________________________________________

Sponsored by:
ThinkGeek at http://www.ThinkGeek.com/
------------------------------------------------------------------------
leaf-user mailing list: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/leaf-user
SR FAQ: http://leaf-project.org/pub/doc/docmanager/docid_1891.html

Reply via email to