On 19 Feb 2011, at 15:41, Gerard Ashton wrote:

> On 2/19/2011 10:24 AM, Joe Gwinn wrote, in part:
>> I have not been following the proposal in detail, but a key issue to the 
>> POSIX community is that their timescale must be implementable in a totally 
>> isolated machine, one having no GPS or internet access.
>> 
>> There are other requirements as well.  This was discussed at length on the 
>> Time Nuts reflector, until Tom kicked the thread over to Leap Secs.
>> 
>> Joe Gwinn
>> _______________________________________________
>> LEAPSECS mailing list
>> [email protected]
>> http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/leapsecs
>> 
> 
> I think a description of the totally isolated machine requirement would have 
> to be specified
> to make progress. How long would the machine be expected to keep good time, 
> what is the acceptable
> tolerance for time of day, and what technology would be used to keep time?

With respect to leapseconds, a debate starting from a  completely isolated 
computer is almost meaningless.  Leapseconds represent a one part in ~5x10^7 
divergence (0.02ppm) from TAI+initial offset.  Even if you can find a 
free-running crystal oscillator of that precision given constant temperature, 
the environment in a piece of computer hardware varies in terms of temperature 
sufficient to throw that off by more than 0.02ppm, and (whisper it!) computers 
have been known to drop clock interrupts at a rate at least comparable to 1 in 
5x10^7. Show me a computer that can run its operating system clock, ie the 
return value from time(), such that it gains or loses significantly less than a 
second over the course of a year and we can talk about the semantics of Posix 
time relative to leap seconds in an isolated environment.

Now it's possible that one scenario is a machine which is hooked to a 
Caesium-Rubidium clock, but has no means of obtaining DUT1 or leap second 
notifications, but nonetheless needs to track UT1 or UTC to high precision.  I 
think that use-case needs to be articulated before it's used to hold this 
debate hostage, because I'm struggling to think what it is.

ian
_______________________________________________
LEAPSECS mailing list
[email protected]
http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/leapsecs

Reply via email to