On Feb 21, 2011, at 11:32 AM, Poul-Henning Kamp wrote:

> Would abolishing leap seconds make timekeeping less or more complex ?

See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complex_question

You are assuming that leap seconds are a free parameter that can be abolished 
(or redoubled for that matter) at will.  Rather, leap seconds are a means to an 
end, and that end addresses requirements in the problem space.  Those 
requirements won't vanish even if leap seconds do.

If the ITU wants a timescale without leap seconds, and if that timescale must 
be distinct from TAI and GPS, then they are free to define a new timescale.  
The pertinent requirement that was identified in Torino in 2003 was that such a 
timescale shall be called something other than "UTC".  Ignoring this 
requirement doesn't mean it goes away.  Presumably the leapless timescale would 
have to be called something other than the "volt" or the "ampere" or "kelvin" 
or "Avogadro's Number" or "pi", too.  A timescale without leap seconds is none 
of those things, just as it would not be UTC.

Similarly, "Coordinated Universal Time" is subclassed from "Universal Time".  
Universal Time in its various forms provides a realization of Greenwich Mean 
Time.  Greenwich Mean Time is layered on the "synodic day".  By kicking the leg 
out from under UTC, all the contingent complexity would slide into a tangled 
mess on the floor.  Yes, this would make timekeeping as a whole significantly 
more complex.

...but then, the ITU doesn't care about timekeeping as a whole, do they?

Rob

_______________________________________________
LEAPSECS mailing list
[email protected]
http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/leapsecs

Reply via email to